I set aside some time this morning to take stock of my life and the various gifts I received over the hiatus. Among the goodies: a milk chocolate cauldron filled with marzipan vegetables commemorating the night attack by Savoyard in 1602 (Thanks, Rachael), a boxful of Tim Tams for the cast and crew (The chocolate mud rocks. Thanks, Sel), a collection of the “Very Worst Opening Lines in Fiction” (Thanks, Pauline), a hand-knit black scarf with a fiery J (Thanks, Kellie), a selection of holiday inspirations (No accompanying card, so thanks to someone in Alberta), a handmade cappuccino-scented hand soap modeled after a dog turd (Thanks to Moe Jacuzzi), and a multimedia player for my iPod and DVD (thanks, SciFi).
Just a little reminder to check out tonight’s People’s Choice Awards broadcast. Stargate Atlantis is up against Dr. Who and Battlestar Galactica in the Favorite SciFi Show category. If we win, I’ll celebrate by seeing how drunk I can get on champagne truffles.
I enjoy reading a variety of books. My reading list is made up of not only diverse genres, but diverse sub-genres as well. Take science fiction, for instance. In any given month, I may read a couple of classics, some post-apocalyptic offerings, a smattering of space opera, and even an occasional scifi romance. Okay, by “occasional”, I mean “just this once”, and, specifically: The Time Traveler’s Wife, by Audrey Niffenegger.
Now it’s not that I’ve got anything against romance. It’s just a genre that has never really piqued my interest. However, the premise of Niffenegger’s novel intrigued me enough to test the waters. For those who don’t know (Which would mean you didn’t read the book. In the words of Gomer Pyle: “Shame, shame, shame!”), it’s a love story about a couple, Henry and Clare, whose relationship is complicated by Henry’s unfortunate susceptibility to involuntary time travel. One second he’s lying in bed or sorting books in the backroom at work and, the next, he’ll be standing naked in a meadow, or naked in an alley, or naked (well, you get the idea) more often than not popping up into the life of his future wife, Clare. The story jumps backwards and forwards in time, focusing on the events of a given jump as told from the point of view of either Henry or Clare. For instance, Clare may tell us about the time she was 12 and had a 42 year old Henry paid her a visit, or a 34 year old Henry may tell us about the time he popped in on a 32 year old Clare. Like I said, a very interesting premise and, although somewhat confusing at times, fairly solid in its time-travel logic. Kudos to Niffenegger for keeping it straight and offering a well thought-out sequence of time-shifting events. However…
As much as I found the premise intriguing, I found the characters far less interesting. Henry is, well, a bit of a poseur jerk while Clare’s sole purpose in life seems to be to moon over Henry. Although it was clear that these two were in love, I was never really certain why. What attracted Henry to Clare? And, more importantly, what attracted Clare to Henry? Of course, one possibility comes to mind. Given that Henry starts popping up in Clare’s formative years, it seems likely that she fell for the mysterious stranger she is destined to marry. Okay, but did anyone else find it a little creepy that Clare first lays eyes on Henry when he pops into her life when she is a four year old tot playing in a secluded meadow? Did I mention that he travels naked?
While the internal rules of time travel the book sets up for itself are admirably adhered to, the characters’ attitude toward time travel is not. At one point in the narrative, teenage Henry travels back to pay his 13 year old self a visit and, in yet another disturbing scene, ends up being caught in a, uh, compromising position by his father. Since his future self knew that his father would catch them, his younger self asks why he didn’t do anything to which his future self replies that the future has already been set and cannot be changed. Alright, but in another sequence, Henry ends up giving Clare some upcoming lottery numbers to help secure her future. At one point, the couple experience the events of 911 and, in the back of my mind, I was thinking “So, you WON’T prevent 911 but you WILL cash in on the lottery?”
Henry’s disappearances and reappearances are, conveniently, rarely noticed by other observers. He’ll either be in bed or working alone when he disappears. Given the seemingly random nature of his affliction, wouldn’t it be likely to happen at least once or twice while he was in public? Probably, but this would open up a can of worms (The inevitable questions and potential involvement of outside forces [ie. The government]) that would have taken the narrative in a completely different direction. Still, it seemed a little too convenient that no one ever witnesses this guy pop in and out of existence.
After Henry discovers that his condition is a result of a genetic disorder (!), I asked myself why the couple would be so selfish as to bring a child into the world knowing he/she could inherit the same condition. Again, it affords the author the opportunity to introduce a couple of very interesting scenes in which Henry is visited by his future daughter - but it still leads me to wonder whether logic was sacrificed in favor of an interesting idea.
Overall, because the characters interested me far less than the actual premise of the novel and its narrative structure, I wished the book had been two-thirds its present length (The lovingly detailed explanations of Clare’s paper designs did little to enamor me to the character). Still, The Time Traveler’s Wife does posit some interesting philosophical questions and its last scene, the final meeting between the two lovers, is truly heartbreaking. I’m sure the upcoming movie will do well.
Tuesday, January 8, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

10 comments:
JOE!!!
Stargate Atlanis won best Sci-Fi show!! Personally I voted several times and I am very happy as SGA is my favorite show!
YAY! How can I use some more exclaimation points!!!
Congratulations on the win!
SGA WON!!! This is great! How many truffles have you had now?
I first read The Time Traveler's wife about five years ago and fell instantly in love with it. I found the premise, tone and style of the book to be very different than the other books I was reading at the time and was impressed beyond words.
Since I loved it, though, I have to disagree with a lot of the points that you made.
1) Henry does disappear in front of other people. Not often, but it happens. In fact, he does it in the middle of the street after leaving Doctor Kendrick's office for the first time (in chronological time, not a time-trip), and seeing it actually happen is what convinces Dr K to help Henry in the first place.
2)I didn't find it confusing at all. I found it incredibly easy to follow and, in retrospect, am amazed that she managed to keep the time lines matching up to one another when certain other authors (say, JK Rowling) couldn't keep simpler facts straight.
3)Henry is, well, a bit of a poseur jerk. Well he is, to start out with. Ms Niffenegger tells us that herself, more or less. It's knowing Claire in, shall we say Real Time that changes him
4)...while Clare’s sole purpose in life seems to be to moon over Henry.....(The lovingly detailed explanations of Clare’s paper designs did little to enamor me to the character). Don't you see that it's her art which gives her another purpose? Defines the 'self' that is Claire? It gives her something that is completely independent of Henry, something that is solely hers and gives her life other meaning.
5)What attracted Henry to Clare?. Her stability and dependability, two things that were very sorely lacking in his life when he met her in Real Time. Of course, it could always be that first impression thing that attracts most men to most women on site. Or, as Henry says himself, 'And this astoundingly beautiful amber-haired tall slim girl turns around and looks at me as though I am her personal Jesus.'
6)And, more importantly, what attracted Clare to Henry? Well, he 'saved' her, in a way. And he paid attention to her when she was growing up in her Real Time, when not many other people were.
I suppose one could say that Henry was stable and dependable for Claire when she wasn't and Claire was stable and dependable for Henry when he wasn't.
7)Okay, but did anyone else find it a little creepy that Clare first lays eyes on Henry when he pops into her life when she is a four year old tot playing in a secluded meadow? A little bit. But then again, she wasn't four. She was in first grade. I turned six in first grade and was one of the youngest girls in my class. And I find that kids at that age are much more willing to suspend disbelief and are (maybe as a result, or maybe they go together) more trusting.
8)The Lottery and 9/11 and The Incident. Let's be honest. Can you conceive of a way in Henry could have convinced anyone in a position to do anything about it that planes were going to crash into the Twin Towers? Also, the three events are pre-determined, yes, but Henry never has a choice in changing what happens, only his relation to them (I think). So, while the winning lottery tickets are pre-determined, I don't think that the winner necessarily is. And while the Towers were falling down, Henry did have a choice not to be there. Henry couldn't do anything about The Incident because that was something very specifically happening to him.
9)I asked myself why the couple would be so selfish as to bring a child into the world knowing he/she could inherit the same condition. It is pretty selfish, yes. But you have to remember that they didn't realize that the Time Traveling is what was causing the miscarriages right away. And in fact, it's a younger Henry, a more desperate Henry, who ends up getting Claire pregnant, one who doesn't yet know that Real Time Henry and Claire and have decided to stop trying.
(Yes, the two Henrys in bed with Claire was a bit...odd.)
10)I’m sure the upcoming movie will do well. I'm actually very frightened of what they'll do it and will be very hesitant to see it once it comes out.
Atlantis won the People's Choice Award.
http://www.gateworld.net/news/2008/01/istargate_atlantisi_wins_peoples.shtml
Congratulations on the Win mate! I hope you enjoy your champers and Truffles!
Congratulations on the Best Sci-Fi Show Win! I can't believe I missed seeing it on TV though! My friend called me and yelled at me that they won. Great job, SGA! Good luck with the champagne truffles! =]
YAY! SGA won! Congratulations to you all and its well deserved... Thats why I went over and voted as often as I could. Hope you didnt make yourself too sick with all those truffles Joe.
Hugs
Wendy
John Sheppard is my happy place
First, a big congratulations on The People’s Choice Award - that’s great!
Second, honored to have FF1 chosen, if a little guilty that it beat out the wonderful Kay Kenyon.
And finally, would be more than glad to answer questions. I’m currently organizing my thoughts (”state of the field” and all that) for the introduction of FF2, so it’s great timing!
I wonder if the new class wraith cruiser will appear in The Kindred
Post a Comment