So where do people who work in the food industry like to go when they eat out? That’s the question I asked the kitchen crew at one of my favorite Vancouver haunts last month. Their surprising consensus pick: Rekados Grill, a Filipino restaurant on Main Street. And if that wasn’t enough to convince me to check it out, the sous-chef’s recommendation to “try the crispy pork belly” certainly was.
Rekados is located in a strip mall on the corner of Main and King Ed., and while finding parking can be a bit of a pain, the extra five or ten minutes spent circling the block is quickly forgotten once you step inside the clean, modern dining room and are immediately enticed by the aroma of garlic, scallions, and roasted chicken. On the night we visited, it was hopping. The place was three-quarters full and we just managed to snap up one of the two remaining unreserved tables.
We started with the calmare, garlic and chili-spiced lightly-fried squid topped with sweet red onions and served with cilantro mayo. Crisp and utterly delicious - I‘d go so far as to say the best in town. The manila street barbecue (chicken or pork skewer - in our case, both - with spiced coconut vinegar) and the tinkling chicken (tender pieces of boneless wok-fried chicken) were also tender and flavorful, but those calmare were a mighty tough act to follow.
For mains, we went with the suggested crispy pata, a slow-roasted pork hock that is crispy-fried before serving. I found it a little overdone, but Fondy adored it. The rekados chicken, marinated in house spices before being slow-roasted and, yes, crispy-fried, was moist and fragrant. Feeling adventurous, I ordered the sizzling sisig - chopped pig ears and pork tossed in sweet red onion, scallions, chilis, and soy, served on a sizzling platter - and was rewarded with a dish that delivered on both taste and texture, a little savory, a little tangy, a little crisp, and a tad crunchy.
When it came time for dessert, I was disappointed to learn that they had run out of my first choice, the dark chocolate tastings, so I went with my back-up, a selection of Filipino ice creams while Fondy had the leche flan. Now I’m not a fan of crème caramel but this Filipino version, made with condensed milk and topped with candied peanuts, was richer, firmer and, in my opinion, far tastier than its more popular cousin. As for those ice creams, I was served three flavors on three different spoons: mango, sweet purple yam, and, crazy as it sounds, corn and cheddar cheese. Crazier still is the fact that the latter turned out to be the best of the bunch, a nice contrast of sweet and savory. While the mango proved suitably “mangoey”, the purple yam underwhelmed.
Despite the almost full house, we had no complaints with the service.
As we left, stuffed and satisfied, I couldn’t help but wonder where the Rekados’ kitchen staff goes when they eat out.
Today's pics: The place, drinks, calmare, skewers, crispy pata, the house chicken, sizzling pig ear, leche flan, 3 types of ice cream including cheddar-corn!
Today's video: Click on the date to see us "clap Carl out".
Today's mailbag:
Marichka a ecrit: “1) Maintenant que vous avez le temps de souffler, ca sera plutôt des vacances en vue pour se reposer ? Ou plutôt des livres de SF pour ne pas dormir ? 2) Pourra-t-on dans un futur proche ou lointain, voir votre nom sur une production pour le grand écran ? Ca vous tenterez ? 3 ) la question pour faire bonne figure et ne pas sortir du lot : Comment va votre voiture ?”
Reponses: 1) J'espère que j'aurai le temps pour tous les deux. 2) Il ne m'intéresse pas vraiment. Je préfère la télévision. 3) Il fonctionne bien.
Dustin writes: “hey joe i was wondering what type of camera do you use to take your photos? and are you a buff of photography??”
Answer: I know little about photography beyond the basic “point and snap”. And there are times when I can’t even get that right. I use a Sony HDR-SR1.
Lt.ColShepJumper writes: “How is Earth able to manufacture another ship that fast?”
Answer: Presume that Earth is in the process of building several ships simultaneously. Each is in a different stage of development so that when one is eventually put into service, its demonstrated strengths and weaknesses are noted and subsequent models are tweaked as they near completion.
Nathan writes: “Looking back at the scripts you have written for Stargate over the years, which was your favourite / most fun to write? Which one didn't turn out as well as you had hoped? What was the name of the first Stargate script you wrote and the name of the last (so far)? Which one didn't translate to film so well for you and which one turned out far better than you imagined? Which was the most difficult to write?”
Answers: Favorite - Ripple Effect. Most Fun to Write: The Ties that Bind. One that didn’t turn out as well as I’d hoped: Irresponsible. First script: Scorched Earth. Last script: Kindred I. One that didn’t translate to film so well: Irresponsible. One that turned out better than I imagined: Camelot. Most difficult to write: This Mortal Coil.
Anonymous #1 writes: “Were you one of the 2.7/7 (7.29 million) that tuned in to see the Bayou Bengals - Fighting Tigers of LSU - whump on University of Florida Gators?”
Answer: I was. And also one that tuned in to watch Carl’s USC Trojans upset by Stanford. I hear Carl hasn’t stopped crying.
MajorSal writes: “wonderful cast photo!:I have a question regarding that: who's the blond gentleman sitting next to amanda?”
Answer: That is our immensely talented Production Designer James Robbins.
SMB Books writes: “Hard cover or paperback?”
Answer: Usually paperback but, like you, if it’s a new release from an author I enjoy reading, I’ll splurge for the hardcover.
Vikitty writes: “Have you ever seen Infernal Affairs with Tony Leung, Eric Tsang, and Andy Lau? I'm guessing you've seen the American remake (The Departed). Which one did you like more and why?”
Answer: Yes, I saw the HK version of Infernal Affairs and, to be perfectly honest, preferred the original. The American version was good but didn’t strike me as an improvement over what I had already seen.
Yet Another Flanigan Fan writes: “Is there any significance in the fact that David Hewlett is sitting front and centre in the photo, while the lead actor in the show is off in a corner, or was it just an accident?”
Answer: David, Amanda, and Jewel were one of the first to arrive and so settled in at the front. Joe and Jason (as evidenced by a clip I posted sometime last week) were late to arrive and so picked the nearest available spaces.
Anonymous #2 writes: “ Who does the big black dog belong to? Is that you with your hand up on the side of your head. Is that the day that you whacked your head on the trunk of your car?”
Answer: That is John N. Smith’s dog, Heida, who is scared to death of Jason and growls at him whenever he comes near. Yep, that is me on the day I was whacked by my car trunk door, doing my best to oh-so-casually conceal my head wound.
Edward4th writes: “I'm somewhat surprised that Baron Destructo doesn't have more minions, why is that do you think?”
Answer: The Baron has a nasty habit of offing his minions when he’s feeling grumpy. He’s not good with goldfish either.
Michelle writes: “The NY Times has an interesting article about the new ratings system. Apparently it takes Nielsen 21 days to do the Commercial + 3 day ratings analysis!”
Answer: Thanks for the link to a great article. I’ve already copied the guys. Hmm. A 21 day wait for the +3 ratings? Great. That means we’ll probably receive the proper ratings for our premiere a little after we’ve already learned our fate.

72 comments:
Any word on Lifeline's ratings?
I hope that SciFi urges on the side of caution. They really don't have any other shows with the name recognition Stargate has. Battlestar is flying off into the sunset soon, Flash Gordon is painfully cheesy (and not in a good way), and Eureka is cute but it doesn't seem to have the kind of rabid fanbase that gets a show (and by extention a network) talked about. Not that my opinion matters, of course, but with the string of mistakes the network has made since breaking up the stellar line up of SG-1, Atlantis, and Galatica I would hope they'd hold on to one of the only shows giving the network the kind of identity the people working for it would be proud to have. My 2 cents... :-)
So if SciFi does go and do something hugely stupid and axes Atlantis, where do you think the show will go from here? Will there be movies like SG-1? Or might you move to syndication only or another network?
Hello Joe from Florida!
I was just wondering which has more Shep whump, Doppelganger, or Travelers and is there any certain reason why there were places back-to-back?
Excellent show. :)
So, I noticed you eat out a lot. Do you ever cook for yourself and how gourmet do you get? It's macaroni and cheese, isn't it? It's okay. That's about the extent of my cooking abilities.
Also, I just picked up a combo of Niven's The Integral Trees and The Smoke Ring. Ever read it and if so, what did you think?
:D Skip
You use a video cam to take your pics? I've gotta be honest I cringe at some of the low light shots, but I'd be loathe to critize, better low quality pics than none at all.
May I suggest you invest in a Fujifilm Finepix F31fd or F30? They're sometimes hard to find but the F40 and 50 do a pretty good job as well.
I use a DSLR myself, but I have an F31 as backup and the image quality is stunning for a little point and shoot camera.
Thanks for the great food picks, they're a great inspiration in seeking out some new cuisine.
How do you feel about larger-breed dogs like Labs? When you chose your dogs, was it more based on their personalities, or did was size a big factor too?
Thanks for a great show in Lifeline of Friday. It's going to be a great ride this season I can tell from these first two episodes...and I'm looking forward to every second of the ride.
Still have fingers and toes crossed for a 5th season. It would seem to me that SciFi would give you a year heads up like they did with Galactica...but then, who am I to even begin to know how the PTB at a TV network might think.
Hi Joe, those drinks look lovely; and next time I make creme caramels I shall try condensed milk instead of cream.
BTW, I came to your blog because a friend told me you had a lovely picture of Joe F on set, but I discovered a whole lot more.
Thank you (((HUGS)))
Congratulations on receiving a (very rare) perfect 10 from IGN on only your second episode as show-runner...
http://tv.ign.com/articles/825/825529p1.html
I expect many more to come this season (and next!).
OK, I like Where's Wally, but I can't see Rachel Luttrell in the cast photo... little help?
So.. David H is now a Daddy. This show really does seem to attract the little babes.
I got Atlantis season 3 the other day.... doesn't it seem silly to you that in Australia we get the dvd before it even airs on tv?
By the way... keep up the good work. :)
Why is Carl all packed up like that? It looks as if he's...moving out. You're making me nervous with that vid and the one of Joe F. skateboarding off into the sunset.
Please answer this question. Is Jacob Carter going to be on Atlantis or in the movies, Continuum or Ark Of Truth [Yes, I know that he died in Threads]? Thanks.
Hi Joe
I'm pretty sure season 5 is a done deal (one reason "syndication"). As I think season 5 will be the last please bring back Jack for a couple of episodes (that way you can express better whatever was cut out of "Trio").
Hi :) Those drinks look really tempting, btw... Fingers crossed for season 5 and ratings--I watch live when I can, but I have to work most Friday nights so I definitely record and watch the next day if I'm not home.
I'll finally come out of lurkerdom to ask a question. It's been said that Zelenka gets some nice moments with most of the characters in Season 4, which I'm really happy to hear. David Nykl said on his blog there were 10 episodes with him in it, whereas earlier reports had been 15. Can you confirm a number? Sorry if this has been asked before and I missed it....
A technology question here:
was the Hot Zone "nanovirus" created by the Asurans? Or were those nanites a prototype version? because the Asurans could not tamper with their base code.
Thanks for answering my question, and I'm glad you didn't take offence. The thing is, a friend of mine insisted that the photo was evidence of the show turning into Stargate: McKay. She still insists that that’s what is happening - but she was arguing that even before the photo appeared. Then, when I say that it’s still Stargate: Atlantis as far as I can tell, she says, “You mean Stargate: Sheppard, don’t you?”
Do you have any Wraith stunners going spare?
The cast photo reminds me of the panoramic senior class photo my high school took; the type where several students would try to get in the picture twice by standing on one side and then running behind the group of students and repositioning on the other side.
What is that thing in the jar next to the skewers? It looks like a teeny tiny Junior.
I absolutely adore Ube ice cream but it's hard to find really good stuff outside of the Philippines. In fact, it's hard to find a really good Filipino restaurant outside of the Philippines. There are a few good ones around here (I live in Seattle), but nothing that really grabs me. I guess I'm a little bias having lived there a lot of my life and my cooks pretty often. Oh well.
Thank you for answering my question.
The way I see it, there are three ways to view Atlantis's characters (in order of "main-ness"). In order of "biggest" to "smallest". (For season 4.)
Sheppard>Carter>McKay&Teyla&Ronon>Keller&Zelenka&Lorne>Chuck
(I believe fans of this group would like Weir to be there, next to Shep, but not sure)
Sheppard&Carter&McKay>Teyla&Ronon>Zelenka&Lorne>Keller>Chuck
(My group, because I believe this is the what the show is supposed to be, and I love McKay [would like him to be main character w/Shep].)
Sheppard&McKay&Teyla&Ronon>Carter&Keller>Zelenka&Lorne>Chuck
(Understandable, the team, then their boss, and you get the rest.)
I was wondering whether you could say which group you guys were aiming for (Don't use the fact that mine's the 2nd, ignore I said that [please].) Or can you not say?
I think all the characters get enough action, although Shep is overly whumped (my opinion again, just ignore that), but I also realize some fans do like him the best, so I get why you do that, or was he supposed to be the main character, and everyone else supporting? Like, Sheppard>Everyone Else.
Sorry if my 'Q was too long, or confusing. I'm just curious!
I thought "Lifeline" was excellent. Torri got to show what she's capable of -- I don't imagine it's easy to show depth and remain stoic and machine-like at the same time. I thought it was a tour-de-force for her.
Once again, Joe showed some great acting chops with his banked emotional depths.
Loved the Ronon and Teyla scene, not because I want to see them as a couple (I'd rather have no ship at all), but because it is so rare to get to see them act, especially Jason. It's great to see Jason actually having words to speak in scenes that allow him to express emotions (both episodes) rather than having to create his own acting scenarios in the background because nobody is writing for him. I may be biased a bit because he was the only bright spot in an otherwise dreadful "North Shore" but I think you have a very good actor there with lots of potential coming. Anyway, I hope you continue to give him scenes in which to shine. I'd say the same about Rachel, but you've already indicated you are planning more for her.
McKay is McKay... David's always good.
I can't say I find Michael Beach all that believable. I'm not sure he's found the roles he's best suited for yet. I do hope you can bring back Mitch Pileggi soon -- he was very believable -- I don't recall any pilot with him in it being picked up but the memory fails with age. Barclay Hope was also a very believable ship commander, but you killed off his character.
Anyway, kudos to the writers and director for a second great episode of the season.
Mmmmmmm....calamare and crispy pork hock. (drools)
Thanks for describing "tinkling chicken," because it sounded like the chickens drank too much water and were looking for a bathroom. ;P
Despite your fate being DOOMED!, I hope you have a lovely evening.
1.If the unimaginable gets imagined and Atlantis gets cancelled, are your new pilots that you are writing sci-fi or a different genre?
2.Would you stay and write for Brad and Rob on the new spin-off if that were to get picked up instead?
3.If Atlantis gets picked up for a fifth season, will you be show-runner or will Brad and Rob be back? If not, what will they be doing?
Sheppard fan, you and your friend are both wrong. It's Stargate Carter. Remember that.
And Elizabeth JACOB IS DEAD!!!! DEAD!!! Stop asking the same question over and over again.
If JM hasn't answered it, take the hint that he's not going to.
kind and gentle anonymous said: "And Elizabeth JACOB IS DEAD!!!! DEAD!!! Stop asking the same question over and over again.
If JM hasn't answered it, take the hint that he's not going to."
i think elizabeth is trying to find out if jacob might be returning in some kind of alternate universe or timeline thing.
i don't believe joe's going to answer it, elizabeth, since he's not answered it already. it might be no or it might be something he doesn't want spoiled.
sally :)
Hey Joe. Here's one that just calls for some speculation I think. Were any of the Aurora, Orion or Tria among the Ancient ships bombarding Asuras in Niam's flashback? What happened to the Tria, by the way?
Joe,
Irresponisible was hysterical and one of my favorite light hearted episodes. I wanted to know where Rachel was for the cast photo. I know she is about due, now. My question is did you ever read Madeline L'Engle? I read A Wrinkle in Time in the fourth grade and subsequent books. I cannot believe she died last month. Take care and the show has already surpassed last year for me. The characters seem more together and "human." Here's to 6 more seasons!! Keep up the great work.
So how stressed is everyone about the ratings? Over the top anxiety happening? Carefree nonchalance? Stressed, but too cool to show it?
anonymous anti-Carter sourpuss said... "Sheppard fan, you and your friend are both wrong. It's Stargate Carter. Remember that."
O noes, Carter is taking over the show! She's been in almost ten whole minutes in two entire episodes!!! It's turning into Stargate: Carter!!! /sarcasm
Please. Overreacting much?
Joe - thanks go out to you and the other writers for introducing Carter gradually and subtly. I know some fans will never be happy as long as Carter has even one second of screen time, but this fan is very happy with the way you've brought the character aboard so far. I am really looking forward to "Reunion" this week and seeing Ronon and Teyla get a bit more to do.
Hello,
I tried to post earlier, and it wasn't taking, so apologies if you get this question more than once.
Since you mentioned "Ripple effect" as one of your favorite episodes, I hope you don't mind my asking about Mitchell's cryptic remark, "Cut the green one." THe green what? Did that ever get resolved in a later SG-1 Episode, or in one of the upcoming movies?
-p
A while ago, you featured a picture of Lulu sporting a nifty knitted hat with slots for her ears to poke through. Does Fondy sell those at her boutique? Does she have hats in sizes that would fit a larger dog, like a 55 lb labrador retriever puppy? My sister is raising one for Guide Dogs for the Blind, and I think her puppy could use a hat now that it is starting to get colder.
Thanks for your time!
You need to stop flaunting your purple ice cream. One of the filipino guys on my MR2(Toyota) boards just posted a picture of his. I'm being torchured!
Here's to hoping our next meet is at a Filipino place. I mean, we could have gone Sunday night but we ended up at Chevy's waiting an hour and a half for our low quality food. =(
By the way... I was watching Journeyman tonight and noticed something.. Is the attorney in tonight's episode the same guy who played Simon Coombs in The Other Guys?
Tell poor Carl his weeping is Palo Alto's joy. It's not often Silicon Valley raises its collective head from its Blackberry and takes note of a sporting event, but the place is on fire! Young Tavita Pritchard is the new toast of the Valley, and the Stanford history professors are handing out laurel wreaths to the team. No offense, Carl, but Go Cardinal!
And, your dinner looks really tasty, Joe. :)
Hi Joe!
Loving what I've seen of the new season so far. It's been fab!
We're getting 'Adrift' on SKY 1 tonight. The TV mag. I bought has this synopsis on the episode "The clock is ticking for Sheppard and his crew in a rather literal cliff-hanger from the end of series 3. The ship is left hanging off a cliff leaving the crew with 24 hours of life support..." Heh! We're getting a different version of this episode here in the UK then!! :)
Thanks ever so much for the vid of Joe yesterday. Have you ever had a go at skateboarding?
Joe,
just answer this question from Elizabeth about Jacob, so she'll stop asking it over and over and over again. Considering the fact that Continuum is the time travel movie, Jacob's appearance seems to be quite possible.
Sounds like you've dined at yet another excellent restaurant. I'm wondering, what exactly are the cube-like red and green things on the last spoon of your ice cream dish?
Sorry, going back to the cast picture; who got the honor of holding Lulu?
Apologies if you mentioned it and I forgot.
So your next project is to check out the restaurants that the really good chefs recommend? sounds like a plan.
Hey Joe i was wondering if Rachel is on that cast Photograph at all as ive looked everywhere and i cant find her also could you pass my Congratulations onto David Hewlett for the new additon to his family
Hey Joe. Another short question. Is it you who approves the comments so they are posted visibly or do you have somebody do it for you? You're lucky to have three pugs by the way. I'd like just one. It's a little sad that the only one in my neighbourhood, a black pug, hasn't been around for months.
Joe, I don't even want to think about bad things happening before the 3-day ratings come out, but if they do...I'm sure fans will find something to mail folk in protest. What earthly item would you say epitomizes SGA?
In a S3 commentary Martin Gero says he's not very original when it comes to coming up with character/place names and choses names from family/friends etc. I was wondering what method you use to name your guest or background/minor characters?
Thanks,
Tru
Do you ever have regrets over story decisions made previously? For example, do you ever look back and think "dang, I wish we'd kept Dr. Fraiser on"?
With all the upcoming dramatic scenes and slated angst, do any of the crew become emotionally overwhelmed and display any out of character behavior?
Well not be be a party pooper or anything but after the premiere I predicted 1.3 for the premiere and it got a 1.2 and as hard as it is to say this I am not predicting renewal - I think that the show will be cancelled. Just my prediction though, let's see how good my psychic abilities are, maybe I'll go into business.
So on the off chance that SGA is not picked up for a 5th season, would MGM look into digial distrabution a la Sactuary? That is my prefered method and far easier to track than the messed up ratings system of tv.
On a similar note:
If you could go back and know that season 10 of SG-1 was the last, what would you change about the way the story played out?
☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★☆★ ☆★
Salut Joseph =)
Vous avez ancors bien manger aujourd'hui^^! J'adore cette video de Karl!=D
Ahhhh! Je vient d'aprendre une chose afreuse! Je n'aime pas trop le chocolat! snif, je ne suis pas digne du grand joseph?
Le grand jour approche! encors 8 jours =)
Mes questions:
1)Vous préféré le sucré ou salé??
2)Quel acteur ou actrice arrivé souvent en retard sur le plateau?
3)Quesque vous avez prévu de faire pour votre anniversaire??
Bon bah Merci =)
Gros bisou!
je vous aimre trés fort!
Bonne journée
a demain.♡ ♡ ♡
☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★
My, I see the Canadian Dollar is strong today. In fact according to www.xe.com it is cheaper for a Canadian to visit South Africa than an American. (Quick shameless plug for South African tourism) :-)
If the Canadian Dollar continues to be strong will it affect shooting next season?
Lastly, do you watch Rugby, as in the Rugby World Cup? Just asking, seeing as South Africa are in the semi's...
dede said:
(snip)"My question is did you ever read Madeline L'Engle? I read A Wrinkle in Time in the fourth grade and subsequent books. I cannot believe she died last month." (snip)
GOOD LORD - what is it about this blog? A few weeks ago, I found out about Robert Jordan's death on this blog and now it's Madeline L'Engle.
Dede - thank you for the news. Another creative author that has gone on. Sad.
Weird thing - I, too, read Madeline's books when I was a lot younger. A couple weeks ago, for some reason, I thought about those books and picked them up at my local Barnes & Noble. Cruised through the first two and I'm smack dab in the middle of "A Swiftly Tilting Planet" right now.
It had been so long since I had read them, the stories seem all new to me.
Dang, that is just weird.
SMB_BOOKS
So what did Jason do to Heida that she doesn't like him? Maybe now that he's shaved his head, she won't recognize him and they can be friends. And how are you going to explain Ronon without dreds if, hopefully when, you get a fifth season?
Congratulations on a wonderful fourth season so far! Hopefully it will be allowed to continue into season five.
And congratulations to David on the birth of his son!!!!
WOW! those meals look great. Does it upset you that the sci fi channel cancels shows running a 1.2 and continues to produce and air: super snake, maneater, killer bug movies? Are they rating better than SGA, and what do you feel about that if they do?
All these food pictures always make me so hungry. Not only do you say they taste amazing but the presentations are always so gorgeous. Since I will probably never get out to Vancouver, do you know of any good restaurants in NYC that I should try? (Keep in mind I am strange and the only meat I eat is chicken.)
Again, congrats on the new season. It seems you and Paul are doing a great job.
OK, I have question about the season 4 uniforms. I know that blue is science, yellow is medical, and black is military, but what is red? I used to think that it was civilian, because both Weir and Teyla had the red uniforms, but now Carter's wearing red! I thought she would be wearing black for military. Unless red means administrative or leadership, in which case why would Teyla, as an alien, be considered administrative? Although she has been left in charge of the city sometimes. . .good greif, I'm confused. Can you please shed some light on this? Thank you!
Ratings?? Please!
salut joe ENCORE une fois,je voulais juste te dire: POURQUOI? pourquoi avoir remplacer weir par carter? Je ne comprend pas c'est injuste!!! weir est la laeder d'atlantis.
Il ne faudrait pas comfondre SGA/SG-1!!
va t-on la revoir pour la seconde partie de la saison?
PLEASE respond me!!! THANKS.(3X)
Hey Joe.
I've been trying out a lot of the restaurants in the Kits and Granville areas which you hype so often on here, and so far you haven't steered me wrong. Thanks!
I haven't been reading long, so maybe I missed it, but have you tried Zakkushi? Some of the best Japanese I've had in the city!
Hey Joe,
Cute way to get your computer screen cleaned!
http://comedyoption.com/pics/monitor_cleaner.swf
I bet Lulu could do the same thing!
Kimberly
stargatemagic said...
"Sheppard&Carter&McKay>Teyla&Ronon>Zelenka&Lorne>Keller>Chuck
(My group, because I believe this is the what the show is supposed to be, and I love McKay [would like him to be main character w/Shep].)"
I think McKay already is a main character. He sure gets more lines than Sheppard and sometimes more screentime! (Tao of Rodney, Grace Under Pressure) McKay is so awesomely flawed! ;-P
Answer: "I'm not sure what, exactly, the criticism is with regard to the banter."
Sorry I wasn't able to get back with you before now. I've just been reading a number of posts on gateworld where some fans have been complaining that the Shep/McKay banter is becoming tiresome, annoying, etc... Some fans are just getting tired of it.
Where the Jack/Daniel banter was a very small part of the 'SG1' series that added to it, the Shep/McKay banter is becoming a large part of the Atlantis series that (instead of adding to) is basically taking over. A few fans even said that after watching 'Lifeline', for the first time ever they didn't like McKay. He's getting the nickname McWhiney.
I know that there were quite a few complaints during season 3 that 'Atlantis' had turned into the Shep/McKay show and it's not fair to judge season 4 because it has just begun. I've always felt that a huge part of what always made 'SG1' successful was that it wasn't the Jack/Daniel banter show or the Jack/Sam ship show or the Sam/Daniel science twins show etc.......
But that it was all of those things added together that made it even a better show.
I was hoping that maybe you could address some of the concerns that I've been reading (and tend to agree with) and could touch on how the banter will be handled in season 4? Thanks Joe
Some friends and I were discussing the chain of command on Atlantis. We know Weir is(was)first and Sheppard is second.(Soon to be Carter first) We figured McKay is third...but after that we weren't sure. On one episode when Weir, Sheppard and McKay were gone(don't remember which one), we remembered Teyla as being in charge. I figured that must have been Weirs decision as I'm sure it wouldn't be proper chain of command (if there is one from Earth). Unless we just 'thought' Teyla was in command...and she really wasn't? Lorne and Zelenka were also mentioned for fourth in command. (no one mentioned Ronon..lol)
So this was long winded...sorry. The questions are:
1.What is the chain of command in Atlantis?
2.How far does it go?
Hey Joe,
So I've watched Lifeline and Adrift now, and I must say it's like I'm watching a whole new show, and not in a bad way.
Stargate has always been like a guilty pleasure for me. The self-referential humour, the sarcasm and the blowing up of spaceships always sort of fit together nicely, though I never would expect the show to air on anything other than cable. I was comfortable with my niche programming and the occasional inside joke that would pop up between me and my brother about how I was "petty, arrogant and bad with people" or how our plan of action was more crazy than blowing up a sun.
Last night, as my brother and I were watching, we decided that had changed. All of the previous stuff was still there, which was great, but I think doing 20 episodes instead of 40 has made a huge difference in the overall quality and professionalism of your work. I could honestly see this season of SGA airing on a network and not seeming out of place, except for the obvious fact that it's a science fiction show. Granted, it wouldn't be America's most watched show or anything, but the quality of the entertainment has noticeably improved. Thank you for doing such a great job, and I hope you continue to do so into season five.
Sincerely,
Copernicus
Anonymous said...
"I've just been reading a number of posts on gateworld where some fans have been complaining that the Shep/McKay banter is becoming tiresome, annoying, etc... Some fans are just getting tired of it."
I haven't gone to Gateworld other than to get information on Stargate stuff. From what I have seen here and on another website I post on, there seems to be a lot of people arguing in disrespectful, adolescent ways on Gateworld. I'm not saying everyone that posts there acts in this manner...but there are enough to ruin it for the rest. Seems like a lot of whiners to me, and if you don't agree with their 'opinion'(not fact), they will attack. I don't put a lot of credence in what people say over there. [not that you shouldn't...I just don't ;~)]
I love McKay/Sheppard banter and have since season 1. If we are quoting people at other websites, then the ones who post at my other website, love the banter too. ;~P
kdvb1 said: "I haven't gone to Gateworld other than to get information on Stargate stuff. From what I have seen here and on another website I post on, there seems to be a lot of people arguing in disrespectful, adolescent ways on Gateworld. I'm not saying everyone that posts there acts in this manner...but there are enough to ruin it for the rest."
I wholeheartedly agree. I stopped going to Gateworld's forum for this very same reason.
I've found quite a bunch of people in fandom at Livejournal and other places that say they've stopped going to Gateworld's forum this year because of the same reasons. The main site is great because you can read interviews, etc with the actors, writers, etc. The forum, not really.
kdvb1 said: "I love McKay/Sheppard banter and have since season 1. If we are quoting people at other websites, then the ones who post at my other website, love the banter too"
I love the interaction between all the characters. And the John/Rodney banter is no exception. I think it's great their friendship has grown so much over the years.
Do you have any tentative date in mind for the release of season 4 on DVD? I just know that it'll take about a million years to reach New Zealand on TV. And the longer the break between season 3 and 4 DVD releases, the greater temptation there would be for one to look at spoilers ... or worse.
Hi Joe,
Just more Qs:
1.) Does the Wraith attack command being executed by the Wraith affect Teyla and other Athosians with the Wraith gene?
2.) Surely the Ancients have a failsafe against Replicator attacks. What would happen to the Replicator processing system, if it encountered the Wraith gene and the Ancient gene embodied in one person? ... but then in Lifeline, Replicators were shooting at John... hmmm?
3.) I may have missed this, but can Teyla self-regenerate like other Wraiths or is she not Wraith enough?
:)
...Eboni
Yo Joe. The Missouri State Symphony Orchestra is playing Liszt's Les Preludes and Tcaikovsky's "Little Russian" suite tonight. I'm excited (I'm second horn). Could I get a dedication/good luck fusion? It's gonna be a great concert!
Oh, by the way, Lifeline blew me socks off. And then I had to find them. They were all the way in Branson. That's how good it was.
ok, time for our daily dose of stupid... what does ship mean? me confuzzled...
kdvb1 said: "I haven't gone to Gateworld other than to get information on Stargate stuff. From what I have seen here and on another website I post on, there seems to be a lot of people arguing in disrespectful, adolescent ways on Gateworld. I'm not saying everyone that posts there acts in this manner...but there are enough to ruin it for the rest."
Funnily enough being a newbie I only just recently signed up at Gateworld and that's been my perception as well. For a place that I thought would be for fans it really does seem to be inhabitated by people that really should have reached for the remote a long time ago.
Thankfully though this hasn't been my experience elsewhere - I just hope that if TPTB ever lurk to measure fan opinion that it isn't limited to Gateworld, because to be frank I don't think they represent viewers at large.
Anyone please, What are the book club selections ?
Hi, Joe.
"Adrift" and "Lifeline" were awesome! Season 4 is off to an excellent start.
The internet reviews are very favorable too! IGN rated "Lifeline" with a 10 out of 10! Woo-hoo!
Thank YOU for all your hard work on the blog, and for sharing the video clips and lovely photos with us.
Here's a list of reviews so far:
"Adrift" Reviews:
http://community.tvguide.com/blog-entry/Ambercolored-Glasses/Stargate-Atlantis-Season/800023442
http://www.pinkraygun.com/2007/10/01/hailing-atlantis-adrift/
http://scifitvfangirl.blogspot.com/2007/10/gaters-paradise.html
http://blogs.ign.com/SCI-FI-BRAIN/2007/10/02/67863/
http://entil2001.com/blog7/
http://tv.ign.com/articles/824/824202p1.html
http://www.syfyportal.com/news424228.html
http://www.tvsquad.com/2007/09/29/stargate-atlantis-adrift-season-premiere/
http://www.tvaholic.com/2007/09/28/review-stargate-atlantis-season-four-premiere-on-sci-fi-channel/
"Lifeline" Reviews:
http://community.tvguide.com/blog-entry/Ambercolored-Glasses/Stargate-Atlantis-Weir/800024072?rssDate=12345678
http://www.fadpov.com/read.php?ID=303
http://blogs.ign.com/SCI-FI-BRAIN/2007/10/09/68440/
http://www.pinkraygun.com/2007/10/08/stargate-atlantis-lifeline/
http://entil2001.com/blog7/
http://www.syfyportal.com/news424264.html
http://tv.ign.com/articles/825/825529p1.html?RSSwhen2007-10-08_133300&RSSid=825529
http://scificrazy.us/2007/10/06/stargate-atlantis-lifeline/
http://www.tvsquad.com/2007/10/06/stargate-atlantis-lifeline/
http://www.tvaholic.com/2007/10/05/review-stargate-atlantis-season-premiere-part-two/
Best wishes, Morjana
Kind of a late comment here, but what the hell-
Re: the corn and cheddar cheese ice cream...
I once had some buttered popcorn sorbet (at The French Laundry). It seriously tasted EXACTLY like buttered popcorn. It weirded me out, to be honest with you. It wasn't gross, just...sorbet that tasted like buttered popcorn. Nothing at all like the buttered popcorn Jelly Bellys. Talk about gross...
Speaking of The French Laundry and knowing how you love chocolate, I thought you should know that everyone who dines there leaves with a box of truffle assortments (and some shortbread). They are mighty tasty.
hi joe -
like everyone else, i have enjoyed your inside scoop on Renuion. i would love to hear more about upcoming eps - can you do that even if you didn't wirte them? i hope so!
Post a Comment