Monday, October 22, 2007

October 22, 2007




I walked into the office today and found a package awaiting me. I could hardly contain my excitement as I tore through the wrapping, just imagining what awaited insie. Chocolates? Books? Unsolicited story ideas that I would have to hand off to Alex Levine for immediate return? Well, none of the above. Feast your eyes on this awesome painting of my four little terrors lazing about (actually, three little terrors as, I hate to say it, but Bubba didn’t make the cut - that’s Jelly pictured twice on the left - nevertheless, a great job capturing their likeness so well that I AM able to recognize my own pooches). A big thank you to the artist, our very own ditraveler. Fondy is going to love this!

Speaking of the dogs, it was Lulu’s first day at daycare today. I dropped her off with the pugs and peeked into the pen to watch her settle in. The second they opened the gate, she scampered inside and was immediately lost amidst a sea of dogs where she either had time of her life or was immediately consume by the pack. I guess I'll find out later today when I go pick them up.

And speaking of sending - I finally sent Pauline off her 500 000th visitor prize: that sample of sand from the set of The Last Man. Accompanying the sand (which comes in its very own eye-catching test tube) is an Unofficial Certificate of Authenticity for immediate framing. Actually, that's not entirely true. I didn't send it. I had Lawren do it. He was still filling out the special sand custom form when I strolled by him this afternoon. "Value of item,"I overheard him murmur. "One dollar." One dollar! How can you put a price on happiness? Especially after you learn - as I did today - that this sand was re-used from the Ark of Truth set. Wow! Two shows in one. Don't you feel special, Pauline?

And speaking of neither dogs nor mail, I’d like to welcome you all to our second Joe’s Book Club of the Month meeting. This month’s selections: in the fantasy category - Stephen R. Donaldson’s Lord Foul’s Bane, an in the scifi category - Niven, Pournelle, and Barnes’s The Legacy of Heorot. Allow me to weigh in…

Lord Foul’s Bane: I have to be honest with you. Although I read The Lord of the Rings in high school, I’ve generally avoided fantasy literature most of my life because, rather unfairly perhaps, I’ve always imagined its offerings as little more than variations on the same theme. Well, that attitude changed once I read the works of Joe Abercrombie, Scott Lynch, and George R. R. Martin. I discovered that fantasy didn’t have to involve: an unlikely and reluctant hero, a quest to save the land, a band of brave supporting players committed to helping the hero attain his goal, a magical artifact (usually a ring), an evil overlord and his beastly minions.

Now Lord Foul’s Bane is a seminal work of the genre, one that was recommended to me on numerous occasions and one that I finally got around to reading last week. To those of you haven’t read it, it tells the story of Thomas Covenant the Unbeliever, an unlikely and reluctant hero, who undertakes a quest to save “the Land”. Accompanied by a band of brave supporting players committed to helping him attain his goal, he is armed with the power of White Gold imbued in the magical artifact he sports (a ring actually). But even that may not be enough to defeat the forces of the evil Lord Foul and his beastly minions.

I don’t doubt Donaldson’s talent as a writer, but I didn’t find this book as significant as some had led me to believe. When I gave Rob Cooper my honest opinion, he admitted that he’d had a tough time getting through the first half, although it picked up for him in the later stages. According to him, the second book in the series is when it really gets good. Another reader shared my initial misgivings, but insisted that things really pick up in the third book of the series. Second or third book of the series?! Talk about infinite patience. If not for the fact that it was a selection in my own book club, I probably wouldn’t have finished this one.

For starters, while I understand that the protagonist, Thomas Covenant, is an anti-hero, I found him a lot more anti than hero. When he first appears in the book’s strange otherworld, he is befriended by a young girl who rescues him and takes him to her village. He repays her kindness by sexually assaulting her. Now I realize that he will presumably seek redemption over the course of the book series but, to be honest, I have a very hard time mustering up much sympathy for a rapist. Call me hopelessly old-fashioned in that respect.

As for the adventure itself, much of the narrative is made up of our anti-hero complaining and feeling sorry for himself, or pages of backstory on the Land that we learn second-hand from its denizens who punctuate the travelogue by breaking into song now and again. It was tough going.

In retrospect and given how many people loved it, maybe I’m just the wrong audience for this book.

The Legacy of Heorot: Shades of Aliens! The members of a self-sufficient colony are threatened by a fearsome resident of their new homeworld. But in dealing with the problem, they unwittingly create a much bigger threat.

Legacy turns out to be a fairly quick read, occasionally bogged down, I thought, by the creature POV segments. While I didn’t find the relationships between the various characters all that engaging (and someone has already noted the fact that the female characters were a bit thin), I did find the development of the battle between colonists and grendels very interesting. In particular, I liked the way in which a study of the creatures’ biology offered up the means by which to defeat them. I also liked the late twist - the realization that the colonists have actually exacerbated the problem by screwing with the new world’s eco-system, setting up the novel’s climactic showdown.

Granted, as far as science fiction goes, Legacy of Heorot is more popcorn fare than most - but nevertheless, a fun read.

Today’s pics: ditraveler's doggy masterpiece, The Last Man sand and accompanying unofficial certificate of authenticity, Hey! Check out Marty G.'s Stargate SG-1 The Complete Series boxset (with new and improved gate symbols!).

Today’s video: Click on the link to see Lulu’s first day at daycare.

Today’s mailbag:

Amz writes: “I'm wondering, what's been happening in the World of Joe's Psedonymous Email Persona's? Anything of note?”

Answer: Things have been unusually quiet on that front of late. I’ll have to check in with Hazzencockle, Baron Destructo, and Cookie Monster.

Charles Schneider writes: “ What's your favorite cut of red meat/beef? How do you like it prepared?”

Answer: Rib-eye. Medium-rare.

Zabadoo writes: “So, four great episodes in a row and counting, are you surprised of the positive fan reaction to them or were you expecting it?”

Answer: I never know what to expect. I will say that I thought the first four were strong episodes, and feel the same about this week’s episode: Travelers.

Emily writes: “Have you ever eaten bone marrow?”

Answer: Yep. A local restaurant, Le Crocodile, does a terrific roasted bone marrow.

Vikitty writes: “…have you checked out the West Coast Chocolate Festival yet?”

Answer: I didn’t. As much as I enjoy chocolate, I didn’t feel like taking the drive to Coquitlam. Did you go?

ARF writes: “I think it sounds like a poor defense/excuse for unoriginality.”

Answer: I see it as an evolution of a concept created for the show - like the goa’uld, the wraith, or any other elements that have been revisited and developed over time.

Bekki writes: “What do the Stargate Atlantis crew do with all their trash?”

Answer: It is beamed onto hive ships. That’s why the wraith hate us so much.

Anonymous #1 writes: “In Progeny, Niam wanted to ascend. So, is it possible for machine like him reach ascension?”

Answering: Interesting question.

Anonymous #2 writes: “I just wanted to ask if the enormously awkward chitchat Keller had with Carter after she announced Heightmeyer's death was an emergency medical situation?”

Answer: Yeah, I told Robert to run any use of the Keller character by you first, but he evidently forgot to do so. I’ll have to have a talk with him.

Anonymous #3 writes: “Just what does Keller bring to SGA that Beckett could not?”

My Name is Scott answered: “HOW MANY times to people have to be told that Weir and Carson were NOT gotten rid of FOR Carter and Keller. The decision to bring Carter and Keller was made AFTER the decision to rid Weir and Carson... why is this hard to get?? Wow!”

Anonymous #4 writes: “This is not an attack on jewel Staite, casting her as a junior doctor or a junior scientist or junior archaeologist may have worked but this is frankly ridiculous.”

Answer: So, you buy the near-instantaneous travel through a wormhole? You buy the life-sucking aliens? But you have a hard time accepting the possibility of a young virtuoso?

Kdvb1 writes: “If we want to send something to one of the main actors, would it still get to them if we send it to the studios?”

Answer: Sure. Send it to: Stargate Atlantis - 2400 Boundary Road, Burnaby, B.C., V5M 3Z3.

Anonymous #5 writes: “what are the best and worst aspects of working in the Sci-fi industry?”

Answer: Best - You can be as imaginative as you want to be when coming up with new worlds, races, and situations. Worst - As a genre, it is afforded little respect from the general public.

99 comments:

Charles Schneider said...

I also had a hard time making it through Lord Foul's Bane so I sympathize with both you and RCC.

Ribeye is great. I still compete a lot for swimming and cycling so I usually only eat a lot of red meat when I've had a really hard workout.

How do you feel about eating fish? Any favorite in particular?

Anonymous said...

are you not allowed taking them to work or is it just ezyer if you have to work in the office for a day doing book work writing ext to not have to look after them?
Dustin

Anonymous said...

I read Lord Foul's Bane several years ago on the recommendation of a boyfriend who very much enjoyed the series... and I have to say I couldn't force myself to plough through it again, even for the sake of your esteemed book club. So my contributions are from memory... but my memory of finding this book really slow-going and a chore to read are very fresh. ;)

I kinda found the character of Thomas interesting, though yeah, the whole woe is me thing got a bit annoying, but my main problem with the book was just that it was soooooo slooooooow. Nothing happened for pages and pages and pages and every single plot development took three chapters and a wash of backstory and description to actually come to anything and it just bored me.

Mind you.. it has to be said.. much as I do enjoy fantasy books, I've never really succeeded very well in reading Lord of the Rings either. :/ I've never gotten more than a few chapters in. I guess I like my high fantasy a little less wordy and with a bit more pace. Ironic, perhaps, given that, as a writer, I am terribly wordy! :lol:

I do recall that the 2nd and 3rd books in the Thomas Covenant series were.. well, if not better, then at least more happened in them so they held my interest a little more. I even tried starting on the second trilogy but found it equally as slow-going as the first lot and admitted defeat part way into book one.

Stephen Donaldson... a good writer but just not to my taste.

P.S. I did warn ya, during the voting didn't I? ;)

Unknown said...

This has been bothering me, is there a reason why MGM spells Ronon's name as Ronan? I mean based on your posts (and how I've seen on many sites) the canon is Ronon and yet MGM keeps using the other spelling. Accident on their part?

KC said...

I understand commentators need for negative comments. It's sort of a free world. You can criticize/ridicule/guess/rationalize all you want, but at the end of the day, it is what it is....Something I enjoy. Whatever happens with the renewal, I want to the thank the Stargate franchise and all who work there, for providing me escapism and a 'happy, happy' place to go on Friday nights. Of course it doesn't hurt that Joe Flanigan is soooo easy on the eyes! Thank you!

Anonymous said...

"So, you buy the near-instantaneous travel through a wormhole? You buy the life-sucking aliens? But you have a hard time accepting the possibility of a young virtuoso?"

Heh, heh, I love this response. It's funny how, as fans, we are quite accepting of all sorts of weird alien stuff but mess with the main (human) characters and we don't like it one bit. I guess it's because we know how far we can stretch the boundaries with human characters but the sky's the limit with aliens.

That's the beauty of Stargate. It is different from a lot of other sci-fi as the characters are based in the here and now and not at some point in the future. This is, I guess, why some of the fans can be a little more picky when it comes to character development.

Anonymous said...

That video is adorable. Was Lulu ok with all those big dogs? She looked a little freaked out but I am sure she stood her own.

I can't wait to see what prize you give for the 600,000th visit! How can you top that sand? Touched by greatness.

Thanks for keeping me smiling.

Anonymous said...

Hey Joe.

Tabula Rasa: More humorous, or more serious and angsty?

Great name by the way. And, love your dogs. I have a toy poodle and a German Shepherd... love them to death.

Have a great night.

Anonymous said...

Wow! The doggy day care looks (and sounds) like my back yard! All you need are a few horses and a couple of barn cats running around and I would have sworn you were peeking over my fence. Looks like Lulu was going to have a good day. In the event your daycare can't take them, they are always welcomed in my backyard. Of course they have to come to So. Cal, but what the heck. But if you come, bring a fire extinguisher - we could use the help.

Anonymous said...

My personal way of viewing these stories is 'things just happen', yes I would have liked Beckett to have stayed too. But in real life these things do happen, and now we're at the point in life where things are different for the characters. Keller is a good addition imo, as is Carter. But you do sometimes lose good people and even though I would have liked Beckett to have stayed I will not say it shouldn't have happened. As in real life these things DO happen. I just think that some fans don't see that and don't see the show perhaps in a way it should be shown. You can't always control these things. And people who are not liking of Keller is for the wrong reasons and I think the character is coming off well. But some people won't accept it, but I guess that's how some things work.

Three questions:
1. If sci fi do choose to not renew the show, or to renew it how will that decision be made public? Will you mention it on here first or will Sci fi release a statement of some kind?
2. Do you ever consider getting famous actors (as in not just within the genre) more often to see if interest in the show or episode would be boosted?
3. And do you sometimes scroll around different stargate fan sites in order to get a wider perspective of the reception to the episodes or just stick to the one or two?

Anonymous said...

I know this isn't a popular opinion among Stargate:Atlantis fans, but I'm really glad that Weir is gone. Carter is perfect--she can do anything! :-) I am excited to see how she's going to whip the Atlantis crew into shape!

Über said...

(reposting because I'm a dolt who lost track of the time)

Joe...

I think Keller's a neat character. I was all set up to not appreciate her because I miss Carson...but her personality, her self-deprecating wit, won me over.

I also liked the aside she had with Carter after Sam performed the unenviable task of announcing the death of a friend and colleague to the expedition. I thought it was nice for her to show Sam that she appreciated what she said. I'd love to see a friendship form there.

I'm disappointed though that Teyla hasn't gotten in on the love. Will Sam and/or Jennifer interact with Teyla much? I know Keller will in an upcoming episode (drawing a blank on the name...Missing? I think?) but what about Carter and Teyla?

Thanks...MB

Anonymous said...

You ate bone marrow! Gross! What were you thinking? That can't be kosher!


Bekki writes: “What do the Stargate Atlantis crew do with all their trash?”
Answer: It is beamed onto hive ships. That’s why the wraith hate us so much.

Well that explains the whole 'You will die, you are lunch' thing. Thanks.


People are complaining about Keller's age? Why? I always thought that kid geniuses were cool [she's like 17, right?]. The only complaint that I have about her is that she seems a bit spoiled.


Please answer my questions. 1) Who is Ronon quarantined with in the episode Quarantine? 2) In the episode Submersion what does it mean when Teyla tells the Wraith Queen that she has little to lose? 3) What is the air date for Trio?

Thanks!

Unknown said...

Oh you got it! great!

Glad you liked it! hope Fondy liked it too.
I was afraid to make that mistake with the pugs!
my apologies to Bubba.

Happy belated birthday anyway!

Franklin said...

On 19 October 2007 you answered:

Answer: Well, I spoke to him a couple of days ago and sent him an email yesterday afternoon but, believe it or not, this topic never came up. Instead, we ended up discussing ratings and ADR. Go figure.

What is ADR?

Susan

Arctic Goddess said...

Hi Joe:

Would you consider living in the United States if an American series offered you a writing position? And would you consider ultimately becoming a U.S citizen like William Shatner and Alex Trebek chose to?

Patricia

Anonymous said...

I am sad that Weir's gone, and I know you probably don't have anything planned beyond Season 4, but is it possible for her to be in more episodes in the near future? The reason I'm asking is because we ALL know Ford is not coming back anytime soon, and RSF only came back for four episodes- just like TH. I guess I just want Weir's reduction to recurring status to be a real opportunity to develop her character, not just to have an interesting one-time plot.

Tesajb said...

Sweet! I love surprise gifts! Speaking of, have you checked your Cookie Monster email lately?

PG15 said...

You can't fool me Joe. The amount of time I've spent with that flocking by my side, as my wing man, my..."number 1", as it were; the Carter to my O'Neill, the McKay to my Sheppard, the Ronon's gun to my Ronon, the East Pier of Atlantis to my tower of Atlantis, the baldness to my Gary Jones; it has not damaged me one bit with its fatal poisonousness or in anyway attempted to kill me, not even by strangling, as I thought it might.

I have proven you wrong Joe; what do you say to that?

Amz said...

That's a very impressive artwork you have there Joe!

It sounds like I don't have to regret not reading Lord Foul's Bane too much from what you've said. But I'm looking forward to the next books for your book club.

Dori said...

Hi Joe

You beam your trash onto Wraith Hive ships? I thought beaming technology was from the Star Trek Series? You Know... "Beam me up, Scottie" OOps better not say anything about the Scots.. I agree whole heartedly with your assessment of The Thomas Covenant Books. It was recommended by a friend and I just couldn't get past half of the book. And I hate not finishing a book. I am reading "The Blade itself now" and I like it..

Your LULU is such a looker. Those little ears of hers really shout class.

Take care

Dori

Anonymous said...

I know it's really late coming, but I was out of town and just barely saw Doppleganger last night.

Wow.
Just, wow.

Please pass on my compliments to RCC. Brilliant.

Thanks!
:D Skip

Riley said...

Hey Joe,

I watched Doppelganger over the weekend, and after seeing it - and the three previous episodes - I've gotta ask: You did leave some of the budget for the other episodes to come, didn't you??? Wow. They have been looking fantastic. Not just the effects, but also the set design - it's looking really slick and "scifi" this season ... well, moreso than previously. I guess if we start seeing cardboard extras and rubber monsters over the next few weeks we'll understand why. :-)

Very, very nice work.

PS: So - how was the cholestorol? Was the second night at the piggy feast a bit of a last hurrah in case you got some undesirable results from your physical?

Anonymous said...

Is the mini gate on the picture that Marty G is holding real? can i place my hand through it and pull out anything that may be interesting, if so, can we dial the asuran homeworld and make a V simple before quickly removing our hands? :P

squeakiep said...

Not sure what all the fuss is over Keller. Having recently retired from Navy medicine, in remote duty stations [which the Pegasus galaxy would certainly be] a LCDR can be the senior medical officer [SMO], and Keller has at least that much experience if not more. So, IMHO she more than qualifies for the job as SMO.

And for some reason I just noticed the medicine cabinet last week...reminded me of my days on Diego Garcia!!

Anonymous said...

Is there anything you won't eat?

I wonder since I find myself watching the travel channel's show Bizarre foods, As I yell at the t.v "Noo!!!! No!!!! like a mad woman as Andrew Zimmern eats chicken uterus and goose tongues and head.

Oh yes...now he is eating black testicles C'mon!
and he sais they are creamy!

Anonymous said...

Years ago I read the entire Covenant series (I would read ANYTHING sci-fi or fantasy), and never could bring myself to like or even tolerate the character. The whole rape thing just made me dislike the guy so much I always wondered why anyone would write his story.

Anonymous said...

My brother (who is not a fan, of you or anything SG related), wanted to add, "There are wormholes, and ray guns, and this normal human being can jump 35 feet. IT'S FICTION, DON'T QUESTION IT!" What he said more eloquently afterwards, was that if we're to believe this, maybe there should be more young virtuosos on Atlantis? Personally, I see what you're getting at and although I agree with my brother, I also see that you've got to start somewhere.

Anonymous said...

I get that the decision to add Keller and Carter was after the decision to get rid of Weir and Beckett. What I don't get, and I'm sure a lot of others as well was why the decision to get rid of them was made in the first place. The only answer we get is that you wanted to shake things up and to be honest that just upsets a lot of people because we liked things how they were. No fault to Carter and Keller, both good characters, I just prefer Weir and Beckett.

Anonymous said...

Any word on whether or not Joe F and his family are safe from the fires?

I am so looking forward to Travelers, that will make 5 rocking eps in a row! This season so far is awesome.

AV eddy said...

Wonderful drawing of your puppies - ditraveler is a very talented artist!

I hope Marty G. wasn't too close to the DVD wormhole when it kawooshed! I didn't see any blood, so I'm assuming he held it the requisite distance.

What's up with people not liking marrow? Since I was a wee one, I would a bit of beef marrow when my mom fixed steak. Dad would split the quarter-sized piece between me and one of my siblings. Doesn't taste like chicken, but it doesn't taste like crap either.

Once again, great choice in fave red meat/cooking temp. I agree 100%.

*Look! My arteries are hardening!*

JM's Book Club: Lord Foul's Bane: The Post

This was a difficult book to finish. I enjoyed LOTR, and have read the trilogy several times over the years, but I can't see myself ever reading this book again. The big problem I have, besides the constant complaining, was the rape. Ugh. I don't want or need that kind of crap in my life - even when the rapist gets his due, such as in Mercedes Lackey's books. I kept expecting Thomas Covenant to be punished for his crimes, to pay for the sacrifices everyone in the Land was willing to suffer so he could complete his "mission." But no!! Grrrr. Sigh.

I didn't even understand how the rape could have occurred?! He says at one point he's impotent, then he thinks he's in a dream, and commits this heinous act. BUT! We are supposed to realize he really is in the Land, but he can have sex with someone there, but couldn't at home? Right after it was made clear his ailments hadn't been relieved at all (yet). I'm glad at one point he learned to feel bad (too little) for what he had done, but "anti-hero" is the best term for him, besides "non-hero."

I realize this book was written in 1977, and we know the 70's weren't the most enlightened years for women, but FCOL, dude! Every women threw themselves at Thomas?! Lena's mother should have stabbed Thomas in the heart (and elsewhere) several times!

*pauses*

There were too many LOTR conventions in this book. I kept thinking, "J.R.R. Tolkien set a standard, but you don't have to rip him off!"

I think the choice of using a leper as the (anti) hero was interesting, but even that seemed to be dropped after he left Atiaran at the river. I know the Land seemed to be healing him, but there were some definite gaps in logic and health.

I didn't hate the book completely, and I did finish it, so it must have had a few redeeming qualities. They were...uh...it was a JM Book Club selection? Hmmm...there were Wraiths? I like horses?

Actually, the one thing I could/would agree with Thomas Covenant is that many of us (in this world) survive without beauty.

Pg 284 "It means that beauty is something extra," he rasped. "It's nice, but we can live without it."

And that makes me sad. :(

the22ndday said...

I look forward each day to popping on my computer, kicking off my shoes and enjoying your blog entry each day. But I am from Southern California. San Diego area to be exact, and today I am in an evac center. I don't know if I have a home to go back to do to the awful fires we have blazing all around us. Sure could use some good thought from you and others sent our way. Thank you again for your time and energy and allowing us a peek into your world. ~Donna

Anonymous said...

What is the candy you most like to find in your trick or treat bag?

Promogirl said...

Lulu looked like she'll be the boss of all those dogs by the end of the week. Too cute.

Two quick questions. Will Carter make any decisions this season that will cause her to seriously question whether she's the best person to lead the Atlantis expedition? And if she does, who will she turn to for support?

RebeccaH said...

I couldn't find Lord Foul's Bane anywhere (actually, I didn't look terrifically hard), but from your description, I'm rather pleased I didn't.

So, on to The Legacy of Heorot. It's interesting you mentioned Alien, because my first thought on reading the book was Alien meets Robinson Crusoe. I wonder how much of the book was influenced by that movie, at least as far as the monster goes. There were a lot of similarities, for instance the triangular head, the man-skewering tail, the penchant for ripping bodies to pieces, and the semi-intelligent ability to observe and learn. There was a time I would have loved the book, but after all these years, Legacy's Grendel was just a little too rubber suit for me. Still, it was entertaining, very cinematic, if a little soapy (did I mention how much I hate unrequited love stories?).

There were also similarities to our very own Atlantis: Avalon, the lost colony cut off from Earth; Cadmann, the Lone Hero bound by honor to protect everyone even at the sacrifice of his own life. The selfish, flawed, ultimately heroic friend who stands fast. Joseph Campbell would have a field day with this book (yes, yes, I realize it's a retelling of Beowulf, the archetype of hero stories [/spoken in Rodneyvoice]).

But the descriptions and the action were realistic. I expect human beings would be mating like rabbits in a situation like that, without undue regard for all the Earth rules they left behind -- honored in the breach, you might say. The only thing I found totally unbelieveable was the unrealistically low number of humans expected to populate a world. I know we humans did it on Earth over a few eons, but at much genetic expense and contamination, usually resulting in infanticide. Two hundred humans are simply not enough to overcome that kind of thing without extensive gene manipulation, and this book was written before that science left the realm of scifi and became real.

I give the book high marks for suspense, though. Toward the end I really wondered if the colony was going to be wiped out, or left to struggle for a few more miserable years before an inevitable end (I also hate bleak, ambiguously despairing endings - which is why I've come to dislike Battlestar Galactica). This book at least had a sort of upbeat ending: there's still great danger, and more struggle and death in the future, but in the end, the superior, intelligent species will win out.

I wouldn't read the book again, but overall it wasn't bad.

Anonymous said...

Let's be honest. Lord Foul's Bane is pretty crap. I found Covenant's continuous guilt and disbelief grating. However if you have infinite patience (or just got all the books on special at the one time like me before reading them), the Second Chronicles of Thomas Covenant is really good.

Anonymous said...

It looked like Lulu wanted to go home.

pettygrew

Anonymous said...

Have you ever tried hot chocolate? Not the drink, chocolate made with some type of pepper or other heat inducing spice.

Just wondering because my friend owns a candy store and hot chocolate is becoming my favorite. I like it since you feel the heat, but you can't taste it.

Anonymous said...

well, I just saw Doppelganger and it was fantastic! My compliments to the "chefs".

I really loved the part where McKay warns Sheppard about things being really messed up in his head. It was interesting to note that he didn't seem too worried about having Sheppard "in his head" though, especially after his experience with Cadman in Duet. Ah, probably easier to deal with a guy being in his head since he'd be more likely to understand what's in there. Funny comment at the end about thinking there'd be more women in Sheppard's head and Sheppard's seeming surprise that there weren't.

Also, there must be some sort of existential meaning in Sheppard beating himself up when the entity returns to him. I'm sure he was feeling guilty about having touched the crystal and bringing the entity to Atlantis in the first place, particularly since it resulted in Kate's death and, as far as he knew, McKay's.

I also thought it was interesting that Sheppard would be getting himself pounded into the pavement by the entity, despite it being "him", but I figure it was more the "guilt" than anything and it took McKay's appearance to show him that he's not the one to blame for what happened -- it's just how the crystal entities operate -- at which point he really began to fight back. Until McKay showed up, things didn't look too good for our intrepid hero. Yay, McKay, way to go!! Just goes to show how good he really is by being able to save the day in his sleep! I can just hear him telling Zelenka to top that.

Anonymous said...

I was just curious if you'd read The Doomsday Book by Connie Willis? You seem to read a lot of scifi books, and I thought you might enjoy it. Not sure if it's a little 'young-ish' for you (I read it in a 1st year University English course), but it's quite the good read. Anyways, here's the amazon link:
http://www.amazon.ca/Doomsday-Book-Connie-Willis/dp/0553562738/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/702-5189462-2583211?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1193111857&sr=8-1
It's a cool time travel story where the 'present' is the future, but someone ends up going back to the middle ages with a nifty little ethical minefield of a time machine.
Of all of the books in that course, this was the only one I read cover to cover and without frequent naps every two or so pages.

Jinjifore said...

I really liked the Chronicles of Thomas Covenant when I first read them, and up until the Gap series I enjoyed Donaldson as a writer. Unfortunately, my appreciation for his writing hasn't really stood the test of time.

When I first read the series (1981, I think--there were still two unpublished books at the time), Thomas Covenant's whiny self-absorption was actually something of a relief from the standard noble-and-perfect hero. Ultimately, though, I got tired of all of Donaldson's characters having some of those same basic traits, and it rather soured me on all of his works.

ZoniDuck said...

For Susan The Tartan Turtle (who has asked twice now), from filmsound.org

"ADR stands for "Automated" or "Automatic" Dialog Replacement.

Dialog that cannot be salvaged from production tracks must be re-recorded in a process called looping or ADR.

Looping originally involved recording an actor who spoke lines in sync to "loops" of the image which were played over and over along with matching lengths of recording tape. ADR, though faster, is still painstaking work.

An actor watches the image repeatedly while listening to the original production track on headphones as a guide. The actor then re-performs each line to match the wording and lip movements. Actors vary in their ability to achieve sync and to recapture the emotional tone of their performance."

I'm curious Joe, does SGA require a lot of ADR work, or would you say it's pretty average by industry standards?

Anonymous said...

To the person who asked, you can read about ADR here on wikipedia.

To Joe, I can accept that a person might be a genius and become a full-on doctor by her mid-twenties, but that's different than whether Keller comes across believably. She 'acts' too young and insecure to have such a high position, IMHO.

Sorry, as you might guess, I really miss Carson, and his warmth and confidence.

Anonymous said...

You've said a billion times that you did not get rid of Carson and Weir FOR Carter and Keller, what was the reason for getting rid of them?

Anonymous said...

“This is not an attack on jewel Staite, casting her as a junior doctor or a junior scientist or junior archaeologist may have worked but this is frankly ridiculous.”

Since McKay was building bombs before most people even started learning the maths required, and Atlantis is full of the "brightest and best", Keller's age really isn't an issue. I have colleagues of Jewel's age currently walking the wards fo local hospitals, so it's not far fetched.

Besides, does no-one remember Doogie Howser?!

strivaria said...

Since you're the only Stargate person I can readily get a hold of right now and maybe get a quick answer, I've got a question for you. Who builds the ZedPM and Ancient Personal Shield type props, a group within the studio or an outside contractor (if a contractor, who would that be)? One of my homework questions for one of my engineering classes requires me to write about a company I'd like to work for. Since I've always wanted to build props/models (or be an astronaut), not to mention I'm already building a mini ZedPM for one of my other engineering classes, I wanted to write about the Stargate prop department/company. It's either that, or go with my original dream employers, ILM or the Henson's Creature Shop. Regardless, I'd appreciate any info you've got to give on the subject.

By the way, I love season 4 so far and really appreciated the tidbits you gave us about Reunion as well as Robert's turn at the 'mailbag' for Doppleganger questions.

Anyway, I've got class in 6 hours, so must go attempt to catch some sleep.

Anonymous said...

I understand you reaction to Lord Fouls Bane. You aren't alone in that, it does tend to be a love/hate relationship.

Personally I found the book to be very enjoyable, even if the first one is a difficult read.

After reading lots of fluff fantasy it was refreshing to find a book that had a little more depth to it. Having loved Lord of the Rings I was pleased to find a book that (though obviously influenced - I mean Tolkien pretty much reinvented Fantay Fiction) had a bit more scope and attempted to have a back story and a history. It does not hide its influences but I think it makes enough differences and interpretations to make this his own rather than a cheap copy.


For me I found the story fascinating and gripping. The inner versus external possibilites of Despite and whether the Land was real or not. The characters obvious trauma and action is necessary for the paradox of the story and his actions in Book 1 have far reaching consequences later on.

Anyways, sorry you didnt enjoy, not every book is for everyone!

Anonymous said...

The Thomas Covenant stories are frankly a pile of derivative crap IMHO. The problem with fantasy as a genre is that once you've read Tolkien it's mostly all down hill from there. Few other writers ever seem to be able to come up with anything vaguely approaching originality because they don't seem to understand the difference between being influenced as JRR was by older mythologies and outright cribbing, which is what most of them end up doing. I think the only modern writer of fantasy who does manage to maintain my interest is Clive Barker. His horror is a little too hard core for me but his dark fantasy is often brilliant.

Anonymous said...

How are the ratings looking? can we expect to hear some good news soon? Have you guys got any ideas for season 5 yet?

Anonymous said...

Just wanted to say a huge thank you once again to both you and RCC for taking the time to answer our questions on Doppelganger, specifically my question on the hug scene. RCC mentioned the scene originally continued, but was cut. As much as I want to "hate" him (as he said!), I have to admit I agree with him. The scene is more emotional as is. However, that doesn't stop the desire from wanting to know what was in that cut scene! :)
If you have time, it would be much appreciated if you could give us that cut dialogue as you so kindly gave us the cut dialogue in Reunion. It would mean so much.

Thank you again!
Sara

Anonymous said...

the22ndday said...
I look forward each day to popping on my computer, kicking off my shoes and enjoying your blog entry each day. But I am from Southern California. San Diego area to be exact, and today I am in an evac center. I don't know if I have a home to go back to do to the awful fires we have blazing all around us. Sure could use some good thought from you and others sent our way. Thank you again for your time and energy and allowing us a peek into your world. ~Donna


I hope everything works out for you Donna and that the fires pass you by safely. My thoughts are with you and everyone affected by the fires..

Anonymous said...

Please tell me Lulu has had all her puppy shots and bordetella before being around so many dogs! (Wow, what a lot of dogs!) She is just precious. She looks nervous, but what great socialization for a puppy! She'll be romping around in no time. :)

iamza said...

Comments on Legacy of Heorot:

I really did enjoy readoing this novel, and it took hardly any time at all to finish -- mostly because I found it hard to tear myself away from the story. I particularly liked the buildup of tension in the novel, and the way things came to an explosive head.

Like Joe, I really liked the twist in the relationship between the samlons and the grendels, and that in seeking to remove one problem, the colonists only made things worse for themselves. In that respect, I think Legacy of Heorot is an improvement on the concept behind Alien, where all incarnations of the alien predators were equally deadly. It is easy to imagine a colony becoming complacent when confronted with a lifeform which is essentially harmless (not to mention edible) in its 'tadpole' stage.

I did have a few issues with the way the women characters in this novel were written. For one thing, I think Mary Ann had to be about the most useless character ever introduced into a science fiction novel. What purpose did she serve, save to reiterate ad nauseum for the reader the great benevolence and wisdom of Cadmann Weyland. It got to the point where I skimmed the chapters written from Mary Ann's point of view because my teeth started to hurt from all the grating. Look, these people are meant to be amongst Earth's best and brightest. Yes, Mary Ann lost some of her intellect thanks to a glitch in the cryogenic whatchamadoodahs, but I really hate the idea that the glitch also left Mary Ann with all the personality of a Barbie doll.

There's this throwaway line near the start of the book which hit all the wrong buttons for me:

"Six miles, downhill, and Sylvia was tiring. In the last week, she'd found a dozen reasons to stop. Stones in her walking shoes. Burrs inside her blouse.

Cadmann chuckled inwardly. The colony's biologist was tough, and as stubborn about admitting fatigue as he. She's also three months pregnant. Won't admit there are real differences between the sexes. So be it.
" --From Legacy of Heorot, bottom of page 1/top of page 2

Okay, this is a colony of two hundred of Earth's best and brightest, specially chosen for colonizing a distant planet. You can bet your bottom dollar that the women in that colony would be as capable if not more capable than most men. From that perspective, Cadmann's inward chuckling comes across as paternalistic condescension, and, for me, that's really not an attractive feature in a hero. If anything, it makes me want to smack him upside the head.

By the end of the book, I was starting to think the only reason the women colonists in the book were allowed to come along for the adventure was because the men wanted their wombs to produce the next generation.


Comments on Lord Foul's Bane:

This book is never going to make it to my "must reread" list. I find it slow, and it is filled with poetry/songs that remind me all too clearly of Tom Bombadil of Lord of the Rings. I loathe the lead character, Thomas Covenant, who is whiny and full of self-pity, and completely unsympathetic.

It was explained to me by some big fans of the Chronicles that Thomas does not believe in the Land. He thinks he's lying in the sanitorium in a delusional state, and he is fighting for his sanity the only way he knows how -- by reminding himself that he is a leper, and thus unclean. If he starts to believe in the Land and the people, then Thomas is giving up on the real world, and on ever regaining his sanity. So, the miraculous lifting of his symptoms, the regeneration of his nerves, the return of his sexual potency, these are things that make Thomas angry because they're indicators that he is losing his battle for sanity.

Me, I'm wondering what the heck Thomas is fighting for? Why is he so determined to win his way back to the real world? This would be a real world where Thomas has been rejected by everyone he once knew and loved, where he is outcast and regarded as unclean. Despite his crimes, Thomas is highly regarded amongst the denizens of the Land. He raped Lena, and did not act to save the wraith celebrants, and yet Lena's mother still fought to save Thomas, to get him to the council. He rebuffs Foamfollower's request for a story to make him laugh, and still the giant almost dies in his efforts to get Thomas to the council. Thomas has acted in ways that are repulsive and revolting and despicable, and yet he himself has been treated, for the most part, with the utmost respect. And for all that, all Thomas really wants is to return to the real world...

...Why?

Edward4th said...

Yup, I didn't think you'd be overly impressed with Donaldson. I'm about to go the same way with Terry Brooks too but I WILL give him another shot probably not until I get sufficient time to devote a good day or so purely to reading...after christmas in that case.
Again I can't recommend enough Stephen Kings Dark Tower series.A stellar read!

Paula said...

I am, indeed, truly honored to be receiving that lovely vial of sand. But, most especially, honored to be receiving a genuine certificate of authenticity with it. (Do I get a certificate of authenticity to verify the genuine certificate of authenticity, by the way?)

Please thank Lawren for taking care of the Customs forms. They're pretty annoying in the US. Can't imagine what they're like in Canada. (Can't wait to hear what the letter carrier thinks of this one!)

Thanks again, Joe.

Archana S said...

A couple of questions,
1) How do you feel about Indian cuisine?
2) How many languages do you speak?

firefly827347 said...

Hey Joe. I've not read in a while, university and stuff always seem to get in the way, but I saw a sci-fi book the other day that caught my eye and decided to give it a try. It's called Stealing Light by Gary Gibson, have you heard of it? I'm only a couple of chapters in.

I also wanted to ask if you'd like to stop by your thread on Gateworld once in a while? You don't have to, but if you ever did post there we JM fans would be thrilled. :)

Alan said...

Firstly I`d like to applaud your patience in record to so many people not believing that Weir & Beckett's departure had nothing to do with Carter & Keller's arrival. I`m not sure I would've been as restrained as you have been.
Secondly, I've heard rumours that the 'enemy we long thought vanquished' in the Ark of Truth is the MW Replicators. Can you confirm this or atleast give us a hint. If it is them, bravo for a fantastic twist!

Anonymous said...

Joe about Sci-Fi: "As a genre, it is afforded little respect from the general public."

And I totally do not get that! Especially since Star Wars is the number 2 top grossing film of all time: http://www.imdb.com/boxoffice/alltimegross
Figures only include theatrical box office receipts (movie ticket sales) and do not include video rentals, television rights and other revenues.
ET was 4th, SW Phantom Menace was 5th and Revenge of the Sith was 8th! We Sci-fi lovers obviously put our money where our mouth is!

I have always loved Sci-fi so maybe I am a bit biased. As you have said, we Sci-fi bunch are very techno savvy, and I would love it if they did a study on the intelligence of Sci-fi watchers. My bet is that they are higher on the intellectual scale than many other genre watchers. ;~P
Just IMHO of course! lol
Kimberly
P.S.-Thanks for the answer on your blog btw! I appreciate it.

Anonymous said...

I get that the decision to add Keller and Carter was after the decision to get rid of Weir and Beckett. What I don't get, and I'm sure a lot of others as well was why the decision to get rid of them was made in the first place.

Exactly. When a character is removed, and replaced (by whomever), the writers should have an idea on how to improve the departing character with the new one. So, just why is Keller better than Beckett? And why is Carter better than Weir?

As it stands now, neither Keller or Carter is any better than those they replaced, so why replace the originals in the first place?

iamza said...

Re: Marty's new and improved gate -- I thought there were only seven chevrons on the gate? Are the other two just normally buried underground?

Also, if chevron eight allows one to access a gate in another galaxy, does the ninth chevron allow one access to a gate in another time?

Anonymous said...

1)Will we discover some questionable methods the Ancients may have used during their struggle to survive?

2)Will the Atlantis expedition be forced to ponder some questionable methods themselves this year?

Anonymous said...

I have an off topic question, Joe...

What do you think about Dumbeldore being gay?

Seriously.

WolfenM said...

Awww, Lulu is such a cutie! :D

Now I realize that he will presumably seek redemption over the course of the book series but, to be honest, I have a very hard time mustering up much sympathy for a rapist.

Which is exactly why I've never read that series myself -- I was warned off by a friend who knows my tastes, so I trust her judgment ....

Hmm, I'm trying to think of fantasy books that stay far enough away from the usual formulae that you might enjoy them.

I still highly recommend Charles de Lint (although ... his stuff is *very* esoteric), particularly Memory and Dream, Trader, and Someplace to be Flying.

I adore Anne Bishop's Black Jewels books (I've reread the entire series four times, including the short stories and a book that's set in the same universe but deals with other characters). It's more of a Jane Austen/Victorian-era kind of story (not set on Earth, though), all interpersonal relationships and intrigue. Now, there are a number of plot points of an intensely violent and/or sexual nature that have seriously "squicked" some people I've talked to, but since you read GRR Martin, I think you could handle it.

I love the first three books of Barb and JC Hendee's Saga of the Noble Dead, which tells of a dhampir and her elven companion hunting vampires in a fantasy setting. The vampires are actually pretty sympathetic, and the heroes flawed, so it makes everything a bit more dimensional. I especially enjoyed the second book, but I'm afraid the fourth didn't quite live up to what had gone before -- I liked it okay but didn't *love* it.

I'm still highly annoyed at Jim Butcher for his having put words into the mouths of you and the other producers, but I cannot deny that I love his Dresden Files books, which are almost as much noir (and comedy) as they are fantasy.

Speaking of noir ... if you ever want to read some mysteries, I really recommed James Lee Burke's Detective Robicheaux books, especially Black Cherry Blues, Morning for Flamingoes, A Stained White Radience, and In the Electric Mist with Confederate Dead.

Anonymous said...

In my humble opinion this has to be the best season yet! Great character development, great glimpses into the personal life of the characters. Awesome story lines.

Keller is absolutely lovely - she is meshing well with the others. I'm sure to get hate mail from the SAVECARSON brigade, but although I liked Carson, I find her much more likeable.

As far as Thomas Covenant series goes the 2nd and 3rd book doesn't get better and don't even waste your time on 4,5,and 6. At some point you have to say 'become the hero already! Enough wishy-washy attitude, enough woe is me.'

Anonymous said...

Hi Joe,

Regarding ratings, as Sci-fi Channel knows that Friday night is a poor night for ratings even if a show has a large following (like SGA), do you think they'd consider bumping SGA to say Tuesdays while Eureka is off-air to see if there's a change in viewership?

It would seem to make more sense than cancelling the show outright and losing an investment simply because of their programming/scheduling choices.

Thanks!

Michelle Lunsford said...

Thanks for sharing the vid clip of Lulu's first day at doggie daycare. She looked so happy and eager! Here's to hoping she survived and wasn't consumed by the pack after all. ; )

I'm also having a pleasant chuckle over Paula's prize for her 500,000 visit win. She's a friend of mine and we were just discussing via our live journals that not only does she get the really cool sand - which, trust me, will be right at home in her collection - but she also gets the amazingly cool personally penned unofficial certificate from Joe! Gee, now I have an excuse to drive the five hours to visit her, just so I can see this gem in person. Guess I should say thanks to you for that. ; )

I hadn't commented on Doppleganger yet, but it was great. That was some of the most impressive split-screen work I can recall seeing and fine job on the part of Flanigan portraying so many delightful nuances between "regular John" and "evil John". Looking forward to this Friday night's ep!

Anonymous said...

Hi Joe,

Do you know how "Lifeline" did with the Live + 3 numbers? Also how much does an episode of SGA cost to produce. I know SG-1 was more, but am curious what SGA is per episode. Thanks!

Anonymous said...

Anonymous #2 writes: “I just wanted to ask if the enormously awkward chitchat Keller had with Carter after she announced Heightmeyer's death was an emergency medical situation?”

Answer: Yeah, I told Robert to run any use of the Keller character by you first, but he evidently forgot to do so. I’ll have to have a talk with him.

I'll be glad to render my assistance. All you have to do is ask.

Anonymous said...

hey joe-

to hell with all of the keller haters out there. i think that the writers, producers, etc. have done a wonderful job increasing the danger quotient with the untimely losses of beckett and weir.

while their characters can never be replaced, the mission goes on and their positions must be filled. i think jewel staite and amanda tapping have been awesome additions to the show and i can't wait to see what you do with their characters in the future!

one quick question, are we going to be seeing much of major lorne this season?

Anonymous said...

now i'm reading war and peace and i love it, thanks SGA.

Anonymous said...

When season 5 is renewed, can you get it added to your budget to get Sheppard a bigger bed? Poor guy must have a hard time sleeping if his feet are always dangling over the edge ;)

Anonymous said...

This is a stupid question but I don't care. Do you always take a camera with you when you go out to eat?

Anonymous said...

Jen Keller is SGA's version of Carolyn Lam. Pretty woman-o'-blah.

First time I have to see the team rescue poor, defenseless Keller, I'm gonna be ill!

Eliza said...

Thank you for sharing your latest video. I missed them so much. I loved Lulu protecting her doggie butt. - Eliza

Anonymous said...

Congratulations, Joe! Your little blog is one of the hottest topics on the Our Stargate forums with over 1200 posts!!! Besides the usual Amanda-bashing you wouldn't believe how many of those posts are dedicated to complaining about the fact that you talk about food on your personal blog. No kidding. They're actually mad because you discuss food! On your personal blog!

jolinar said...

Hi Joe, are we going to see any Atlantis bloopers footage sometime?

Anonymous said...

So, you buy the near-instantaneous travel through a wormhole? You buy the life-sucking aliens? But you have a hard time accepting the possibility of a young virtuoso?

Yes we all know this is a sci-fi show, very good, but in order for us to make the leap of imagination into the show we have to believe in the characters, we have to be able to relate to them. Now I am trying not to be sarcastic here (which is very difficult for me as it's my default setting - and believe it or not I actually enjoy getting snarky replies from you, I find it...inspirational) My main criticism is that Keller jars you out of the suspension of belief, oh and we have seen a young virtuouso in the Stargate Universe before, a genius in her late twenties who although totally brilliant held a military rank that was completely age appropriate. If it was important 10 years ago with Sam Carter that the character be believable, why is it no longer important. And just because I can't resist please name me five 'child (or young person) genius's that have actually been successful and popular is Sci-fi?

Anonymous said...

A little info for you, Joe...Canneloni is a tube of pasta stuffed with a meat mixture, Manicotti is a tube of pasta stuffed with a cheese mixture. Both are covered with a red sauce and melted cheese.

Oh, and medium-rare is the ONLY way to eat steak. ;-)

♥ANAIS♥ said...

Salut joseph <3!

Waou! cette peinture de vos chiens est vraiment magnifique!!

Vous mettez Lulu dans une garderie pour chien? génial...Mais ici je ne pense pas qu'il y en est.

Olalal Pauline a vraiment de la chance^^!

Je suis trés fatiguer,vivement les vacances. En plus j'ai une petite surprise pour vous^^!..vous verez la semaine prochaine.^^

Je vais vous écrire une autre lettre ce week end. Il serais possible que vous me répondiez et que vous me donnez votre autographe?


Bon, aller Gros Bisou! A demain! Bonne journée! i love you <3

Anonymous said...

Chelsea said: "I know this isn't a popular opinion among Stargate:Atlantis fans, but I'm really glad that Weir is gone. Carter is perfect--she can do anything! :-) I am excited to see how she's going to whip the Atlantis crew into shape!"

I totally agree with Chelsea. I never warmed up to Weir. I found her to be very bland and boring, and her mannerisms were irritating. To be honest, I think that turning her into a Replicator gave her character a much more interesting twist. I do feel sympathy for the Weir fans, but I am not sorry to see her gone. I already find Carter to be a much more interesting leader, and we're only three shows into the season. I think the producers took a very big risk in getting rid of Weir, but I feel it has paid off.

Vern said...

Anonymous said...
Is the mini gate on the picture that Marty G is holding real? can i place my hand through it and pull out anything that may be interesting, if so, can we dial the asuran homeworld and make a V simple before quickly removing our hands? :P

Answer: No, it isn't. As a matter of fact, it doesn't even spin around. Great decoration, but no, it is not real, Remember the plastic gate from 'Touchstone'? It's the scaled-down version of it. We can't gate to the Asuran replicators' homeworld with it, sorry. Nice thought, though.

Vern said...

one quick question, are we going to be seeing much of major lorne this season?


Answer: Yes. He was in Doppelganger. Future episodes to be determined or Joe can answer.

Janie said...

To Donna (22ndday) and everyone affected by the fires in California, please know that our thoughts are with you.
Here's hoping you can kick off your shoes in front of your own PC very, very soon.
All the best from all of us 'over the pond'
Janie

Anonymous said...

Out of curiosity, now that the show is done with production, will you be taking any time off from the blog? Like a day of rest? Or do you eat out every night? And, hey, do you eat out for breakfast and can you review that sometime?

Victoria said...

Nah... and I probably won't go. I'm drowning in midterms so I don't have time. But I checked out the main website and they've got some pretty neat activities. Bad timing I suppose.

Answer: ... Worst - As a genre, it is afforded little respect from the general public.

Aw, I have to admit, I only stepped into this genre last January, and before that I paid no attention to sci-fi. It's definitely something that needs to be introduced specifically.

As a sidenote, my archaeology prof used Daniel Jackson as an example of pseudo-archaeology. So you're getting free pimpage in archaeology. I also came across Lord Yu in my ancient Chinese history class. Fascinating stuff.

Anonymous said...

Ah, so you've read the Lord of the Rings? What did you think? I personally loved it and the movies.

By the way, is there any chance I could have today's blog dedicated to me? It's my birthday. :D Thank you!!

Anonymous said...

Just curious...are there any actors in movies or TV you would like to see on SGA?

Anonymous said...

I can't believe that people are still complaining about the cast changes! I'm a Weir fan and a Carter fan and I had no complaints about the cast changes. You've managed to slightly reinvent both characters [Weir's part robot now, that could be interesting; and Carter seems a bit softer, in Pegasus Project I was a bit worried that McKay was going to bit the dust.

Anonymous said...

Joe, you actually made it to the end of Lord Foul's Bane??!!! Well done. Being required reading for my Fantasy Literature paper was not enough to make me get past chapter 1. I relied on a friend to give me an over view of the book.

Anonymous said...

Carmen left "House", can he come to Atlantis now? Please!

Aqualegia said...

There's an article in Today's Variety which says that Atlantis has been renewed. YAY!

Variety

Congratulations!

Anonymous said...

I love Jewel Staite. This is possibly because she is awesome, and doing a great job on SGA. I think that season 4 is amazing. This is probably due to (A) you guys turning out awesome episodes, and (B) me not irrationally thinking that I have some sort of claim on the show that makes it possible for me to bitch at you in order to change things that don't line up with my personal view of how a show I have no affiliation with should be run.

In short: thank you for making an awesome show. To crazy fans: shut the hell up.

Anonymous said...

Congratulations on the Season 5 pick up. Hopefully everyone now will understand that they are the minority when they say;

they hate the cast changes, the uniforms, the story lines, the way characters act, the way actors act, the way characters have relationships, how the characters have relationships with the wrong characters...and the list goes on.

Change happens people - if the show was exactly the same as it was in season one, with ALL the same characters you would get bored and stop watching anyways.

Anonymous said...

I think everyone who is moaning about characters leaving should watch 24 and count their blessings. Every episode a character dies! Its grief training. Now when I watch Atlantis its a relief that ONLY Weir and Beckett left. They were EXPENDABLE. GET OVER IT.

Jennifer said...

Yeah!! Yeah!! Yeah!! Just was on Sci-Fi's website. Saw that Stargate Atlantis is renewed for season 5!!!!!!

If you could bring any Stargate SG-1 character (dead or alive) into the Atlantis series, who would it be??

Anonymous said...

Congratulations to everybody for the season 5 pickup. SciFi Channel has finally done something right! (Doesn't make up for canceling SG1 though. I miss my weekly dose of Daniel/Vala bantering goodness.)

I have to second whoever recommended Jim Butcher's books. The Harry Dresden books are fabulous and his fantasy series gets off to a slow start in book 1, but 2 and 3 are wonderful.

Random questions:
1. Since GateCon is coming back to Vancouver next summer, any chance you'll make an appearance?

2. Any word on where you guys are in the process of developing the new SG series?

p-pos said...

the way the wraith in the travellers got punked by sheppard,imo shows a sign of weakness. i was lead to believe they would kill themselves rather then be captured or fail a mission so for that wraith to give back life and walk away is hard to believe.

Azrael said...

Hello Mr. Mallozzi,

Basically I have three questions for you.

1. I am wondering all the time what the function is of those openings or gills on a Wraiths face. Since everything what is attached to a body has a function in nature, I also assume what these openings on their cheeks are?

2. Will we ever find out, how the wraith feeding process really works? I have quite a theory on that. So if you´re interested you can read it on http://www.myspace.com/azrael_sephiroth
It is in the blogsection. It is quite an treatise, but...Well see for yourself if you have the time and the will for it...

3. Will we ever see the Wraith from "Reunion" again? Ahum, we on gateworld gave him the Greek scientist´s name of name "Archimedes"

Alright, thanks in advance and keep on kicking with this luminous show!

One of your greatest ( Wraithed) fans,

Azrael