The t-shirt says “DEATH BIRD” on the front and “FALL FROM SKY” on the back. You’ll be excused for assuming it’s a reference to some lame heavy metal band (“Hey, Death Bird kicks off its Fall From Sky tour this weekend! Awesome!!”). In fact, there’s a story behind the Death Bird t-shirt.
Way back in Atlantis’s first season, then hot young upstart Martin Gero (as opposed to the miserable grizzled veteran he is today) wrote a little script called Childhood’s End which became his very first produced episode of Stargate: Atlantis. The experience wasn’t a wholly memorable one for poor Martin and, some day if you invite him to a con, you should ask him to regale you with behind-the-scenes anecdotes about this episode (which, I’m sure, he’ll be more than happy to supply complete with his trademark funny voices, faces, and sound effects). I remember we were sitting in Robert’s office, watching the previous day’s dailies, when one of the young actors said “Death bird fall from sky!”. Huh? Martin shook his head as if to assure us (but, in hindsight, I believe he was trying to reassure himself). “That’s not the line in the script,”he said. “He’ll get it right in the next take.” Next take: “Death bird fall from sky!” I could see the sense of panic slowly overtake Martin as we got to the third take: “Death bird fall from sky!” Well, at least the kid was consistent.
Even though the coverage was eventually re-shot and the proper line delivered, Martin still ended up disappointed with the final product. Although there are far more memorable lines that did make the cut (Teyla’s “It was too small to be a dart” in reference to a wraith probe that looks absolutely nothing like a dart is my personal favorite), Martin‘s favorite is the one that didn‘t: “Death bird fall from sky.” To commemorate the event, he had t-shirts made for the entire writing staff. I finally wore mine the other day (three years later) after Marty G. complained that we clearly hadn’t appreciated his largesse.
I wanted to follow his lead and done something similar to mark my low-point, Irresponsible, but the costs of supplying the writing department with what would amount to an entire wardrobe of gaffes proved a tad too costly.
Today’s pics: Death Bird - fall from sky.
Today’s mailbag -
Charles Schneider writes: “My puppy once got into a bag of puppy chow when I was away. He was still only a few weeks old, so his whole body ballooned up to hilarious proportions.”
Answer: Yeah, there was the time Maximus got into the trash and consumed the entire portion of Curried Fusilli we had tossed. He was so blimped-out that I was unable to get his harness on and, instead, had to carry him outside for his “walk”.
Thornyrose writes: “When exactly will the final cut of the final episode of season four be done? How many episodes of S4 do you actually have ready for airing at this time?”
Answers: The final cut is done but the episode has yet to be mixed and the visual effects aren’t finished. As for number of finished episodes - twelve I believe.
Anonymous #1 writes: “Sorry I don't know how long it has been since you've last visited Montreal but have you ever been to the Italian restaurant Scarolies?”
Answer: Yep. Not a bad restaurant.
Anonymous #2 writes: “Have you ever tried a Polish cucumber salad called "mizeria"?”
Answer: Fondy orders something very similar whenever we go to The Budapest.
AscendedTauri writes: “Did you try any of the 'Daily Flavor' creampuffs?”
Answer: Sadly, they only had original vanilla when Alex swung by.
Arctic Goddess writes: “What is a wok kitchen?”
Answer: It’s a separate kitchen attached to the main kitchen where we do our stir-frying.
Anonymous #3 writes: “You said that Teyla will be back in season 6...”
Answer: Sorry, that was a typo. I meant season 5.
Morgia a ecrit: “Je me demandais à quel endroit à Montréal Fondy avait acheté les chocolats.
Reponse: Suite 88 Chocolatier.
Annie writes: “is that a dog turd amongst the rubbish???”
Answer: That was my initial reaction when I spotted the mess - but closer examination revealed it was part of an overripe banana peel.
VinsFins writes: “Are we going to see the Apollo and Deadalus in more action?”
Answer: We will in BAMSR.
Anonymous #4 writes: “…you could have answered criticism of how the baby storyline is playing out without blaming the actress.”
Answer: Uh, I was being sarcastic.
Susan the Tartan Turtle writes: “ How come Lulu was at daycare and the others were left home alone? Are they more trustworthy?”
Answer: Evidently not. But she is a handful and daycare does tire her out - much to the delight of the pugs.
Michelle Lunsford writes: “I was curious if your chocolate sampling had ever included chocolate infused with tea flavors?”
Answer: Yes. Christopher Norman Chocolates has a Luxury Tea Collection made up of Lapsang Souchong, Rose, and Mango & Green Tea-Infused Truffles.
Catharine writes: “If the writers had decided to write Season eight (of SG-1) with Sam being pregnant, who would have been the father?”
Answer: No idea.
Tauri Sith writes: “Why don't you like kids?”
Answer: On the contrary. Sometimes, kids can be hilariously entertaining. Check out my December 26, 2006 entry: http://josephmallozzi.blogspot.com/2006/12/december-26-2006.html
Anonymous #5 writes: “Ah yes, because brute force is always so much better than diplomacy, eh? Let's apply the US model of international relations! Invade what isn't yours in the first place…”
Answer: Easy there, Sammy Soapbox. How does that apply to Atlantis? Given the threat the expedition has faced from both the wraith and the replicators, it makes sense that the military would step in as they are in a better position (ie. resources) to defend the city and our planet’s interests in the Pegasus Galaxy.
MaggieMayDay writes: “What part of Japan are you particularly fond of?”
Answer: Love Tokyo.
Anonymous #6 writes: “Hey Joe, any thoughts on the Blue Water Cafe in Yaletown?”
Answer: I prefer their sushi over their regular menu.

70 comments:
Dear Joe did coooooookie monster get my e.mail I sent and did it work and if you already seen it the sorry again. My sister-in-law all she kept hearing where ahhh all day long
so Joe did David Hewlett come in today or is it tomorrow if so give him are thanks and love xx
I only saw Childhood's End once (and I didn't even see the whole thing) but I remember it being a very good episode. I loved the scenes with the two little kids, McKay, Ford and chocolate. It was very funny.
"Tauri Sith writes: “Why don't you like kids?”
Answer: On the contrary. Sometimes, kids can be hilariously entertaining."
Yeah, some kids can be very funny, kind and smart. There's also those other kids who are citizens from Hades. Think they don't exist? Think again. My Italian cousin is the scariest thing on the entire planet and she's only eight. This is just my opinion of her from her visit this summer. Fortunately her behavoir had improved since the last time she had visited (when she was five).
Please answer these questions. 1) Have you ever seen the movie One Night With The King (it's about Queen Esther)? 2) Have you ever been to Disneyland? 3) Which movie are you looking forward to more, Stargate: The Ark Of Truth or Stargate: Continuum? Thanks!
Sorry- posted this somewhere else, not sure where.... so I'm posting this here again.
Joe- you went off on me a couple days ago (the 19th) for calling you a liar and not citing my sources when clearly you know what I was talking about. As you said so yourself;
The first time I answered this question way back when, I said that Torri’s 4 episodes would be in the first half of the season. This is no longer the case
Now, I’m not going to ask for an apology but I would like the to know the title of Torri’s fourth episode in the back half of season four—although if I was a betting gal I would say that it was ‘Be all my sin’s remembered’ because of all the so-called mistakes that Elizabeth has made over the years. Would I win the bet?
(and please don’t be snarky and say no I wouldn’t win the bet or yes you would.... I would like some confirmation, and I’m sure a lot of other Torri fans would like something concrete about Torri’s appearances as well).
Hi Joe:
American holidays suck when they cause interruptions to the Atlantis schedule. I ask you, what could possibly be more important than Atlantis on a Friday night. What are they thinking?
So, you actually have two kitchens - a Wok kitchen and a regular kitchen. Um....why? Is stir fry so stinky that you need two kitchens? Or is that a West coast thing like legal marijuana, moss covered trees and cucumber sandwiches? :)
Patricia
Ha. Loved the 'death bird fall from sky' bit. You guys should definitely consider squeezing it in some future episode. Maybe one of the characters are delirious or something. That would be hilarious.
Andways, any more good Shep-whump episodes coming up?
LOLOLOL.. I love nothing more than obscure references. Even better when they're on T-shirts.
And what sort of video game is that back there? That doesn't look like The Last Star Fighter...
Hey Joe!
I realise Canada is a pretty big place and that Toronto is the other side of the country from you but do you have any wisdom to share on the 'do and do nots' if someone was to be visiting there in the next week or two?
Hi Joe,
Joe F. commented in an interview that Rachel got two months off. Does that mean that Rachel will miss a couple of the first episodes for Season 5?
Since it seems that some of Teyla's arc will drift into Season 5, will you continue with this idea that you had intended for her in Season 4 onto Season 5?
Will there be more character arc plots and further development into some relationships in Season 5?If so, can you state which ones?
Will any recurring characters from Season 4 return for Season 5? Which ones?
Thank you!
Camy
Question- 1. Why did'nt you like Irresponsible?
2. what episode is the proposal scene in.
With Christmas just a month away, are you (or Fondy) the type of shopper who a) buys things year round and saves them until Christmas, b) buys things a month ahead or c) runs around on December 24th, praying that you get to the store before it closes?
So... any chance we can skip the next two episodes and go straight to BAMSR? I'm getting impatient waiting for all the awesome stuff that's supposed to be in this episode, and I don't think I can wait until next year.
P.S. This answer is actually a more polite reaction then the one I actually had when I read your answer to my question
Hi Joe,
Love the shirt by the way.
I have been hearing that there is a new wild fire in Malibu, do you know if it is any where near Joe's and Jason's homes?
Ever tried Bernard Callebaut chocolates?
Have you ever traveled to Okinawa and enjoyed their culinary delights?
I've really been enjoying the season so far, though school has kept me busy and away from your blog! I'm back though, and I come baring a question: Dr. Keller, to a small degree reminds me of Dr. Fraiser; certain aspects of their personalities, the way they interact with Carter, and so on. I think its cool, whether it was done on purpose or not. Was this done on purpose to any degree, unconsiously done, or do you think I'm just losing my mind?
Death bird fall from sky seems like a very poignant and bittersweet memory. I'm sure I speak for a lot of people when I say it's a good thing Martin stuck with it. If he hadn't we wouldn't have gotten some of the most beloved episodes of Atlantis so far like Duet and McKay and Mrs. Miller.
Any recommendations for preparing a chicken-based meal?
Fair warning – this comment is about Weir. If you’re tired of the subject, feel free to move along to the next one. (Except for you, Joe. *grin*)
I haven’t commented for a while, but I’m still a regular reader of your blog. I was definitely anti the cast changes, especially Elizabeth as she is my favorite character. But I really like the rest of the cast, so I’ve given season 4 a chance. Can I see why Atlantis should be under military control? Sure. Does that mean there’s no place on Atlantis for Elizabeth? Absolutely not. There were many reasons she was put in charge of the expedition. Let us see some of her expertise at work. I really hope whatever happens to her, it leaves room for her to return to Atlantis. I miss her rapport with all the other characters.
Season 4 has been just okay for me. I’m happy, though, that SGA has been renewed. Hopefully it will run for many more years – with Elizabeth of course!
Thanks for your time,
Roxanne
Bonsoir Joseph,
Merci pour la réponse concernant le chocolat. Je vais faire une commande à mon frère.
Bonne soirée.
Death Bird ... first thing I thought of was the dead bird ala Death Records in Phantom of the Paradise. I'm showing my vintage.
Mmmm, Tokyo, hop, skip and a 90 minute train ride from Yokosuka. Loved Maggie's Revenge in Roppongi (wonder if it is still there ... been a while now). But then I'm fond of Maggie anything. Not so fond of Dunkin' Donuts, the favored hang spot after the bars closed and before the subway started running.
So Joe... what's your thoughts on the latest season of House so far? Are you enjoying the way they've mixed up the cast and the changes that have been made?
Anonymous said...
Now, I’m not going to ask for an apology but I would like the to know the title of Torri’s fourth episode in the back half of season four
Aside from the fact that, regardless of your apparent sense of entitlement, Joe doesn't owe you anything... has it not occured to you that the fact the Joe - and also Torri herself - have consistently refused to state/confirm what Weir's 4th episode will be is because such information might just constitute the kind of plot/arc spoiler that TPTB don't want revealed in advance?
Joe,
1-When are you going to get on Iron Chef America?? What do you think of Alton Brown. I love his show and his other show "Feasting on Asphalt"!
2-Do you watch Battlestar Galactica? If so, here is a theories of mine:
Ok. Here is my theory(s) on the end of BSG based on insight from tonight:
The final five are the “gods” that we see in Roman/Greek mythology.
Hera (Hilo and Athena’s baby girl) and Chief & Callie’s son (sorry forget his name) will be the “Adam” and “Eve” of either Earth in the beginning
Or
Considering that Kara Thrace is considered the “Apocalypse”, then they are the inhabitants of the new Earth in our future. The 13th Colony was already here.
Just a thought! What do you think?
3-Very much looking forward to "Miller's Crossing" this week. Did you notice the scene in the kitchen that the dinosaurs are on the cabinet and then a few cuts later, there gone??
Have a great week!!
Jen
Catharine writes: “If the writers had decided to write Season eight (of SG-1) with Sam being pregnant, who would have been the father?”
Answer: No idea.
My answer is Jack...!!! I would have definitly done something close to what the writers of XF have done... not the same...but "close enough!!" ;) LOL
Joe, can you help us settle an argument? Do the Quebecois pronounce 90 as quatre-vingt-dix or nonante?
I know the Swiss use the latter and the French the 'proper' first one, but we can't decide on Quebec.
Salut Joe,
Est-ce vous pensez que dans la season 5, il y aura un episode ou Carter parla de la relation qu'elle a avec Jack?
hi, joe,
just finished rewatching 'the seer'; wonderful ep!! i've been waiting 3 years to get a dose of commander carter. it was worth the wait! :D
just sayin' thanks. :)
sally :D
Great shirt! Bound to get you those O_o looks from those who won't know the meaning.
So what WAS the line meant to be? I have to pull out the dvd again...
Oh yeah.. had a thought. How about putting your pugs in an episode of SGA. They could give the Asurans or the Wraith a good going over.
Give em a bullet belt for a collar!
hey Joe I figured as a food expert you'd have a good opinion on what you think are light, but somewhat nourishing/healthy things to eat for somebody who may have lost their appetite. I've had major success with Japanese food the past few days, but that gets quite expensive after a while.
Also wondering if you saw this article in the New York Times on Sesame Street- wondering what Cookie Monster's response is to the terrible things said about him: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/18/magazine/18wwln-medium-t.html
Salut Joseph^^!
Waaaouuuuuuuuhh!! Merci pour les photos de vous! vous êtes trop trop beau ahhhhhhhhhh *je suis sur un petit nuage ^^*
Oulalal par contre le Tee shirt sa ne va pas du tout...lol je suis une fervante protéctrise des animaux a plumes XD....Vive les poules!!!!!!
Ah, vous vouliez dire saison 5, lol mince j'ai eu peur...enfin c'etait une bonne peur ...^^!
Je vous verez bien avec un bébé^^! sa serait adorable^^!!
Hier midi j'ai manger des moules frites miame! vous aimez sa?
Bonne Journée, Merci,
I love you!
I love you!
I love you!
I love you!
I love you!
Et vive les oiseaux....vivant =)
Hi, there is a video on youtube showcasing Atlantis being up for an award, and it has clips from several episodes in it, and one of the clips is a huge firefight with Wraith cruisers, the Travelers, the Replicators and an Earth ship or two. From what you've graciously told us over the last few months this is from 'Be All My Sins Remember'd'.
I know that it would be odd to come out of such a huge firefight with both ships, but please can we not lose one just yet, because the first and onyl other time we have had two 304s side-by-side we lost one (kory/olev) and having two ships really doesn't tip the balance of power unfairly in our favour. Please let them both live, at least for now, we're just starting to make a significant difference in this galaxy.
Though to be honest you've handled like 95% of things in the past really well so I guess I can live with it. The battle does look absolutely awesome by the way
Joe (and Martin G) - love the t-shirt. Any plans for a whole range of them?
Personally would go for my favourite line in "The Hive" - "And that's what you get for backing a brilliant scientist into a corner" - bit long for a t but it's just so McKay. It's not just any scientist, oh no my friend, it's a brilliant scientist. Always cracks me up.
Meils
PS - Childhood's End - meh, commentary on it - great.
What does the Q stand for in Martin Q Gero?
Hi, Joe!
There's a new video clip out promoting the PCA nomination for SGA, and there appear to be clips from episodes later in the season in it:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=pBG5lHpGcTw
Also, Slice of SciFi's new weekly poll is: Top Ten Rated SF Shows on Cable, and SG1 and SGA are included:
http://www.sliceofscifi.com/2007/11/25/slice-of-scifi-poll-for-week-beginning-november-25-2007/
Best wishes, Morjana
"Death bird fall from sky" - what on earth (or other planet!) was the kid supposed to be saying?!! Ah, poor Marty! Glad he stuck with it though, he's written some great eps.
*Sigh* Someone's asking yet *again* for the title of the fourth episode that Weir is in - obviously they don't read your blog regularly or else they would know that you aren't going to tell us because it would be too much of a spoiler for the episode in question. For which I am grateful - I don't mind small spoilers, but I am so glad you don't give out big spoilers despite repeated questions from fans.
So, what happens in 'The Last Man' to make McKay so old?! *wink*
Hi Joe! The US long weekend is almost over. Not looking forward to working Monday... oh well. We can't all have fun and glamorous jobs we love.
Questions - whatever happened to Major Davis?? He just...stopped being in episodes. I thought he seemed like a "nice guy" kind of character so I wonder if it was planned or it just happened? And how 'bout a promotion for Major Lorne?? He's been a Major for at least 5 years!
Thanks :) Wams352
Hey Joe, not sure if you've seen this or not, but... only reason I mention it is because Mckay brought it up in a past episode, can't remember which. Talking about situational ethics. Just wanted your opnion on it and whether you disagree or agree with their definition of morality.
http://www.time-blog.com/graphics_script/2007/moralityquiz/index.html
1)Will personal feelings amongst the team interfere with missions of great importance?
2)Will anyone's mental state become increasingly unstable as the season progresses?
Anonymous said:
"Joe- you went off on me a couple days ago (the 19th) for calling you a liar and not citing my sources when clearly you know what I was talking about.
The first time I answered this question way back when, I said that Torri’s 4 episodes would be in the first half of the season. This is no longer the case"
And you call Joe a liar because of this? *shakes head* Didn't occur to you that at the time he answered the question he thought all the episodes would be in the first half but things changed later (due to production schedule or whatever) and Torri's 4th episode is now in the second half? He has no obligation to make a public announcement every time something he said at a given time is no longer the case later, you know.
Same anonymous also said: "Now, I’m not going to ask for an apology..."
Glad to know, because Joe has nothing to apologize for...
Same anonymous also said: "but I would like the to know the title of Torri’s fourth episode in the back half of season four—"
Considering that it might be an important part of a plot, you won't get the name of the 4th episode in advance, and Joe has no obligation to give you the name.
I think that Elizabeth's appearance in a 4th episode is a plot twist and as that I'm pretty sure it must be top secret and one of those things actors had to sign a non-disclosure agreement about. So you won't hear about it until the episode airs. At least that's my take. Joe would've given the title of the episode by now otherwise.
I looked at the morality quiz that another poster mentioned. I really don't get the Trolley one. Why wouldn't the one man be able to see, hear, feel, or smell the trolley coming? Also couldn't you yell for him to get out of the way? And the other two scenarios, The Crying Baby and The Life Boat, had results that showed that most people would kill the baby and the grievously injured person to save their own skins. What happened to do unto others as you would have them do unto you and all people are created equal? There has to be other options in those scenarios.
me revoila =)
Simplement pour vous dire que j'ai fait un petit sondage sur mon blog.
Quel age on les fan de stargate?
Résultat:
1970 1 voix
1976:1 voix
1980:1 voix
1984:2 voix
1987:5 voix
1988:2 voix
1989:1 voix
1990:11 voix
1991:8 voix
1992:10 voix
1993:2 voix
1994:3 voix
C'est drole de voir que le plus vieux a 37 ans et le plus jeune 13 ans^^ comme quoi stargate touche toutes les génération^^!
aller Kisou!!! =) <3<3<3<3<3
How big of a cliffhanger does This Mortal Coil have?
And what the hell "chevronseven" Be original!
Leesa Perrie said...
*Sigh* Someone's asking yet *again* for the title of the fourth episode that Weir is in [snip] but I am so glad you don't give out big spoilers despite repeated questions from fans.
So, what happens in 'The Last Man' to make McKay so old? *wink*
To which I add
... And apparently leaves Sheppard untouched?
Anne Teldy
hi, could you tell us what episode shep whump fans should look out for next? Thanks.
sgakaz asked on November 24, 2007 5:50:00 PM PST
so Joe did David Hewlett come in today or is it tomorrow if so give him are thanks and love xx
Posted on David Hewlett's Twitter Page at 11:20am Sunday November 25, 2007:
Atlantis commentary for Miller's Crossing tomorrow...today I organize my life!
Hey, Joe!
Just out of curiosity, have you ever considered doing a meet? Just go to a restaurant and just "hang" with some of the blog readers over dinner? Or does the prospect of being covered by your admirers' drool turn you off?
Not that this is of any good to me. I live nowhere no Vancouver. Shame...
Given the threat the expedition has faced from both the wraith and the replicators, it makes sense that the military would step in as they are in a better position (ie. resources) to defend the city and our planet’s interests in the Pegasus Galaxy.
Oh, right I get it now. There's oil in the Pegasus Galaxy, isn't there? So who cares if a few native "primitives" get killed if the mighty US military gets the goodies it believes it's entitled too. Those pesky diplomats just get in the way with all their silly talk about human rights and native entitlement! And who better to have in charge but a proved military stooge like Colonel "Just following orders (and furthering may career)" Carter?
and also Torri herself - have consistently refused to state/confirm what Weir's 4th episode will be
Actually Torri has said that four episodes is over stating the case quite a bit as she was unconscious in one and barely in another. As it seems that Weir has a fair role in "Be All My Sins..." it seems a bit of a moot point which episode what is sure to be her swift and summary disposal will be in.
Joe
Do you have a "Save Carson" t-shirt that you could model for us?
:-)
Is Lulu's best friend still the Great Dane puppy?
Joe, tonight I had the chance to try some Do&Co Catering. It was great. The salad I tried was excelent.
Roastet chicken, with Corn salad, tomatoes, cooked potatoes and a mayonaisse dressing. The best I ever tried!
Should have eaten some more... Darn..
Have a nice Sunday!
Your December 26th entry gave some excellent advice on dealing with young boys. (And it was quite amusing as well.) I especially liked your advice on how to generate an appreciation for literature.
Anonymous said...
"Given the threat the expedition has faced from both the wraith and the replicators, it makes sense that the military would step in as they are in a better position (ie. resources) to defend the city and our planet’s interests in the Pegasus Galaxy."
Oh, right I get it now. There's oil in the Pegasus Galaxy, isn't there? So who cares if a few native "primitives" get killed if the mighty US military gets the goodies it believes it's entitled too. Those pesky diplomats just get in the way with all their silly talk about human rights and native entitlement! And who better to have in charge but a proved military stooge like Colonel "Just following orders (and furthering may career)" Carter?
Wow...
I get an eerie feeling that your next post will say that Bush was behind Wier's replacement and it was Joe that was following orders and furthering his career.
"Anonymous #3 writes: “You said that Teyla will be back in season 6...”
Answer: Sorry, that was a typo. I meant season 5."
Damn... I already started my Anti-Teyla in Season 6 thread on Gateworld.
Now those anti-Carters and pro-Weirs are seriously annoying me... I totally support the decision and think that it makes Atlantis a lot more exciting - and Carson's mysterious return gives me constant food for thought!
Hi Joe - have you eaten in any of the restaurants in Tokyo that the Guide Michelin just honored with three stars? If so, what did you think of them?
Also, thought you might enjoy these photos of another Lulu.
*waves*
Just a quick question tonight. You know how much I love to see people hug. I can't help it, it makes me feel all warm and fuzzy. So, will we get to see some hugs this season? And will I need tissues for any snuffly moments?
And before I go..
"Anonymous who isn't very good at hiding her disenchantment said...
Oh, right I get it now. There's oil in the Pegasus Galaxy, isn't there? So who cares if a few native "primitives" get killed if the mighty US military gets the goodies it believes it's entitled too. Those pesky diplomats just get in the way with all their silly talk about human rights and native entitlement! And who better to have in charge but a proved military stooge like Colonel "Just following orders (and furthering may career)" Carter?"
Have you not had your happy pills anon. I'm assuming given the tone that you're the same anon as yesterday. Still feeling bitter and twisted are you? Do you want to talk about Human Rights? I'm happy to talk to you about them. :D But I don't think here is the time or place, do you? Particular given that 'oil' has never been mentioned in the first place, i'm at a loss to think why you brought that up. Unless of course you're being sneaky and are actually implying that a diplomat is required for when they find all that oil. And let me guess, just in case, Weir should be brought back for just that eventuality. Am I close? ;)
And one last thing before I go, give me one instance where Carter has violated someone's human rights!
Thanks Mr M, as always you're blog is most entertaining.
*hugs*
Cheeky.... (I can't be bothered logging on.)
Hi Joe. I love Atlantis and would like to see more Wraiths. Chris Heyerdahl did a great job with the "friendly" Wraith. I really would like to learn more about their society and I think you should let the Replicators go away... for good. Enough of them. Never thought of adding a Wraith to the team?
I returned home to a similar dog-made mess this afternoon. Apparently the dogs didn't appreciate us leaving them for the weekend with just the neighbor girl to visit them.
Having spent two days with relatives (including an out-of-control 6-year-old) and no internet, I'm very thankful to be back home with my computer and my dogs! I'm not sure we would have survived without the two gallons of margaritas and three bottles of wine Dad bought. I thought he was going a little overboard when I saw the fridge, but he'd already spent two days with the group before I got there, and he knew what he was doing.
"Given the threat the expedition has faced from both the wraith and the replicators, it makes sense that the military would step in as they are in a better position (ie. resources) to defend the city and our planet’s interests in the Pegasus Galaxy."
If that were really true, then Weir would never have been installed as head of the SGC, especially not when the threat to Earth posed by Anubis and the rest of the Goa'uld was at its height and the danger from the Milky Way Replicators was growing.
The fact is, sometimes diplomacy can do more good than a gun. I'm not talking about negotiating with the Wraith or the Asuran Replicators, but rather with the other peoples of the Pegasus Galaxy, for the purpose of an alliance against the Wraith and the Replicators. Despite the best efforts of the Wraith to keep their "herd" subdued, we have seen that there are those that have the technological means to fight and do damage (the Genii, the Travelers, the Olesians before their deal with the Wraith went south, the Satedans before they got culled). The immediate threat of impending destruction on two fronts may bring them all together, but when the threat is over, what will keep them working together instead of going at each other's throats? That is why Elizabeth Weir and her mad skills in diplomacy that were made such a big deal of when the character was first introduced are still very much needed by the Atlantis expedition.
Carter could easily remain as expedition commander with Weir in Atlantis in a diplomatic role. And frankly, it would open up some great writing opportunities for both characters that have been sadly lacking of late. "Ambassador to the Pegasus Galaxy" has a rather nice ring to it.
Hey Joe,
‘Death bird fall from the sky’ cracked me up so hard though not as much as ‘operation magenta’ the other day. You and martin Gero together are bad for my health. Lol.
Anyways I wanted to ask you a couple of question re. Atlantis
1) How do you guys decide on an overall season arc? Is it determined by the stories pitched or do you guys come up with the outline for the series first?
2) Are there any good stories that you wanted to tell but couldn’t because of a particular season arc? If so, would you mind sharing that with us? (though I don’t mind if you don’t)
3) Is there anything that has been set down in Atlantis canon that you guys wish you could take back (in the way that the 3 shots you disappear thing was set down in sg-1 and regretted ever after)?
I hope you have time to answer my questions but even if not, I would just like to say I enjoy your blog and am thoroughly in love with the way season 4 is going.
I'm very happy that Teyla will be in season 5. I know some people aren't all that fond of her character but I like her a lot.
Anyhow, I've been pouring over late-season 3 episodes, trying to locate the mysterious clues that you said were in there pointing to Beckett's return. (I *think* it was you. If not, forgive me.)
Okay, here's the deal: If someone does find the clue and points it out to you, can the clever winner get a special virtual dinner with you? Maybe PG-15 can join in for extra-bonus fun? Just kidding about that last part. Or not.
Hi Joe, catching up with your blog and bringing back the cucumber post... growing up, it was a must to have tuna sandwich with cucumber slices, till today it is my favorite sandwich and now that I think about it, maybe the cucumber has something to do with way I like crunchy texture so much... I'm also a great sushi fan and I go to my sushi restaurant once or twice a week, my favorite rolls are those that have a crunchy texture, one of them has tempura flakes inside and the other surprisingly has apples and I say surprisingly because I'm not a fruit person and I'm not a mixing sweet with salty, but this roll is not sweet, it's crunchy and it's perfect! So what do you like in your rolls? what is the must ingredient?
Anonymous #1 said...
Oh, right I get it now. There's oil in the Pegasus Galaxy, isn't there? So who cares if a few native "primitives" get killed if the mighty US military gets the goodies it believes it's entitled too. Those pesky diplomats just get in the way with all their silly talk about human rights and native entitlement! And who better to have in charge but a proved military stooge like Colonel "Just following orders (and furthering may career)" Carter?
Wow. Someone has a great big chip on their shoulder! And if this were a discussion forum for political issues du jour I'm sure there'd be plenty of people happy to debate the topic with you. However, as it happens, this is a the blog of a guy who enjoys eating out, works as a TV producer and likes pugs. :)
Anonymous #2 said...
Actually Torri has said that four episodes is over stating the case quite a bit as she was unconscious in one and barely in another. As it seems that Weir has a fair role in "Be All My Sins..." it seems a bit of a moot point which episode what is sure to be her swift and summary disposal will be in.
Firstly.. wrong - This Mortal Coil (not BAMSR) is the episode we know Weir is in (and where it does look like she plays a significant role). Secondly... yes, Torri has stated that she is in four episodes but described it as "technically two" as her involvement in two of the episodes (one of which being Adrift where, as she described, she spends most of her time in a coma) is limited. However, the point I made, and which you responded to, is that Torri herself - as recently as last weekend during her talk at the Collectormania con (which incidentally, I was in the audience for) - has refused to reveal which episode is the 4th one in which Weir appears, saying only that she can confirm that she filmed 4 episodes. So my point was, if you - general you - want to have a go at Joe for not revealing the identity of the 4th Weir episode, then by default you are also attacking Torri for equally witholding such information.
Joe,
Love the t-shirt! Its awesome! Where can i get one? Do you like yum cha? I know you like dumplings!
Remember everything can be solved with chocolate!
Cathie
I'm trying to post my Memphis bbq review on my blog, but blogger is freezing when I try to upload photos. So....
In the mean time I have a question.
What time is the sun setting up in Vancouver these days? It sets about 5pm here and it drives me batty.
Catling said...
Ambassador to the Pegasus Galaxy" has a rather nice ring to it.
Lets see .. first there was “Warrior Princess of the Replicators”
Now this one.
I can't wait to see what the next rewrite of the Weir character turns out to be.
random question:
do you know how beau bridges got the role of landry?
did the producers ask him? or did he go through the usual processes?
Anon said...Oh, right I get it now. There's oil in the Pegasus Galaxy, isn't there?
In fact this whole issue is addressed later on in the season when Lt Colonel Sheppard, followed by a contingent of US Marines, invades an Iraqi botanists quarters so that Sheppard might liberate the lamp oil for his large scented candle collection.
At the end of the episode one of the candles accidently sets fire to a curtain burning the room to the ground and resulting in a dramatic gun fight in the hallway where 5,000 people are shot and killed, which is kind of weird when you consider that there aren't that many people in Atlantis. But don't worry, it all ends in a group hug and everyone lives happily ever after until the next episode where a German astrophysist over enthusiastically redecorates their room knocking the wall down into their Polish neighbours quarters.
Wackiness, as they say, ensues.
I had a question that I hope hasn't been answered already. I write reviews for the episodes, and the question as to John's position of military commander in season four came up. With Sam being a higher ranking, military leader as opposed to Elizabeth as a civilian leader who deferred to Sheppard's expertise in military situations, is John's title of "military commander" now irrelevant because Sam has both the experience and authority to make military decisions herself? Is Sheppard now just the team leader and Carter's 2IC, or does he still operate in an almost-joint command position with Sam like he did with Elizabeth?
Sorry if the wording on that question is confusing; I'm not sure I explained myself that well ...
anonymous said:
"Lets see .. first there was “Warrior Princess of the Replicators”
Hey, don't look at me, I didn't come up with that lame moniker. Weir is neither a warrior, nor a princess.
Now this one.
I can't wait to see what the next rewrite of the Weir character turns out to be."
As I said before, when Weir was introduced on SG-1, much was made of her experience as an internationally-renowned diplomat. Becoming an ambassador is a perfectly logical extension to what's already been developed for her character. No rewrite necessary.
Post a Comment